The following information is
presented as
a public service. It may be reprinted without charge -- with
attribution. If
you would like to be added or removed from this mailing list, you may
send an
email to this address.
"Israel is
illegally, and without
justification, destroying Palestinian homes in the Gaza Strip."
FACT
The Palestinian
Authority has repeatedly made commitments
to stop terror
against Israel.
In the most recent agreement, the road
map,
the PA agreed to "declare an unequivocal end to violence and terrorism
and
undertake visible efforts on the ground to arrest, disrupt, and
restrain
individuals and groups conducting and planning violent attacks on
Israelis
anywhere." To date, the PA has not fulfilled this commitment and, as
recently as May 15, 2004, Yasser
Arafat called on Palestinians to "find what strength you have to
terrorize your enemy and the enemy of God."71
In Gaza,
terrorists have acted with impunity since the PA was created. They
intentionally hide in refugee camps and elsewhere among the civilian
population. They do so knowing that Israel will make every effort to
avoid
attacking them out of concern for innocent lives. The civilian
population puts
itself at risk, however, by allowing the terrorists to use them as
shields.
When it comes to homes that
Israeli security forces have
demolished, they are not chosen at random. These dwellings are used by
terrorists as hideouts, bomb factories, and sniper and ambush sites.
Buildings
near the Egyptian border are used by terrorists to conceal tunnels that
allow
them to smuggle arms, explosives and other terrorists into Gaza for the
express
purpose of killing Israelis. The government of Egypt,
which could stop the smuggling and provocation immediately, refuses to
do so.
As is the case in fighting
terrorism generally, the question that
must be asked about Israel's decision to demolish homes is: What
alternatives
are open to Israel? If the Palestinian authorities were doing their
jobs, and
fulfilling their promises, the terrorists would be in jail, the bomb
factories,
closed, and the tunnels filled in. Since they are not, Israel must find
a way
to protect its citizens, and security forces have concluded that
demolitions
are the most effective tool.
Unlike the PA, Israel is
governed by the rule of law, and even the
decision to demolish homes is subject to review by its judiciary.
When terrorists fire at Israeli soldiers or civilians from residential
buildings or activate roadside charges from orchards and fields,
military
necessity dictates the demolition of these locations and international
law
recognizes them as legitimate targets. Israel's Supreme
Court, the most independent judicial body in the Middle East, has
ruled the
army's actions are legal.
Innocent lives have been lost
during Israeli operations. As the
United States has discovered in fighting an urban war against
anti-American
insurgents in Iraq, it is virtually impossible to engage gunmen in
populated
areas and avoid civilian casualties. Like the U.S. army in Iraq,
Israeli forces are defending themselves and seeking to minimize
collateral
damage.
Reports about Palestinians
being hurt describe them being in the
midst of gun battles.72
If Palestinians are shooting at Israeli soldiers, then clearly the
Israelis are
not attacking innocent civilians. And the media never bothers to ask a
more
fundamental question; that is, why do any of the Palestinians in Gaza
have guns
to shoot at the Israelis in the first place? Again, according to
agreements the
Palestinians signed, the only people entitled to have weapons are the
police,
and the PA is obligated to confiscate all illegal weapons.
In the course of Israel's
operations, it is tragic that civilians
sometimes suffer. Rather than blame Israel, however, the Palestinians
should
demand the democratic election of new leaders who will dismantle the
terrorist
networks so that Israel has no need to take defensive measures.
Source: Myths & Facts
Online -- A
Guide to the Arab-Israeli Conflict by Mitchell G. Bard, http://www.JewishVirtualLibrary.org. To
order a copy of the paperback edition of Myths and Facts, click HERE.
Myths
& Facts is also available in Spanish, German,
French, Russian, and Swedish.
Dr. Bard is available for speaking engagements on this and
other
topics.