(will play the following roles)
- Leigh Fondakowski
- Zubaida Ula
- Kerry Drake
- anonymous friend of McKinney
- a Mormon home school teacher
- an e-mail writer
- a reporter
(will play the following roles)
- Greg Pierotti
- Rulon Stacey
- Aaron McKinney
- Sergeant Hing
- Doug Laws
- Shannon
(will play the following roles)
- Andy Paris
- Jonas Slonaker
- Stephen Mead Johnson
- Matt Mickelson
- Russell Henderson
- Governor Jim Geringer
(will play the following roles)
- Jedadiah Schultz
- Father Roger Schmit
- Dennis Shepard
- Jon Peacock
- Phil Labrie
(will play the following roles)
- Romaine Patterson
- Zackie Salmon
- Sherry Johnson
- a waitress
- a newsperson
(will play the following roles)
- Catherine Connelly
- Rebecca Hilliker
- Alison Mears
- Tiffany Edwards
- Kristin Price
- Jen
(will play the following roles)
- Barbara Pitts
- Reggie Fluty
- Connie Miller
- a bailiff
- a newsperson
(will play the following roles)
- Doc O'Connor
- Matt Galloway
- a baptist minister
- a judge
(will play the following roles)
- Amanda Gronich
- Erin Kreifels
- Trish Steger
- Shadow
- a jury foreperson
- a newsperson
(will play the following roles)
- Marge Murray
- Eileen Engen
- Sherry Aanenson
- Lucy Thompson
- Judy Shepard
- a baptist minister's wife
(will play the following roles)
- Stephen Belber
- Rob Debree
- Harry Woods
- Dr. Cantway
- Reverend Fred Phelps
- Jeffrey Lockwood
- Bill McKinney
(will play the following roles)
- Moises Kaufman
- Philip Dubois
- Andrew Gomez
- Murdock Cooper
- Cal Rerucha
- a priest
- a newsperson