There has been a great deal of talk
in recent weeks about the behavior of Indiana basketball coach Bobby Knight
and the sanctions handed down by the University of Indiana administration.
Some say the charges were true, some say they were not. Some say the sanctions
were too heavy, some say they were not heavy enough.
There have been a couple of things I've noticed,
though, that are troubling to me.
The first is the number of people who are defending
Coach Knight by saying that, even if the charges are true, it's no big
deal because it's just "discipline" and "tough love".
This, to me, reflects a real lack of understanding
what discipline and love are. Discipline isn't simply being tough or getting
in someone's face. It's about hard work, self sacrifice, and a commitment
to meeting standards that aren't always easy or comfortable. Someone who
is disciplined is first and foremost self-disciplined. They are under control,
and if the allegations are true, Bobby Knight has clearly shown that, on
many instances, he has been many things but self-controlled is not one
of them.
Similarly, "tough love" isn't simply being tough,
either. The operative word is "love", which involves doing that which strengthens
and builds up for the good of the individual. Any coach who compares his
players with soiled toilet paper is not building up but demeaning. He is
saying that their value is dependent on their success, when in fact they
have inherent value as human beings.
If the charges are not true, then people are right
to defend him, but if the charges are true, they cannot be defended.
The other thing that troubles me, though, is the
response of so many who are watching the scenario play out, particularly
those who are in opposition to Coach Knight.
Whether you think the sanctions were too light or
not, the fact remains that they are the sanctions handed down. It was the
university administration's prerogative to establish the sanctions that
they felt were appropriate, and Coach Knight has been given the opportunity
to change his behavior.
It seems, however, that there are too many people
who do not want to see Coach Knight succeed. They are rooting for his failure.
It's much like those who seem to look forward to the relapses of athletes
who struggle with addictions or with violent behavior. I saw it with Lawrence
Phillips, the troubled running back from Nebraska, when it seemed like
people didn't want to see him get his life together and make something
productive out of it.
Where Coach Knight is concerned, we should wish for
him to succeeed, as we ought to for all people who face similar challenges.
Regardless of whether you think he should remain a basketball coach, he
is still a human being, and his life has value that goes well beyond the
basketball court.
Perhaps we need to be reminded that we all have the
capacity of great good and great evil. We all have within us the ability
to be the next Mother Theresa or the next Charles Manson. When we look
at a Coach Knight, like him or hate him, we should remind ourselves that,
for better of worse, "There but for the grace of God go I." |