Title: A Moment in the Sun Author: prufrock's love Rating: R Keywords: historical au, msr, novel, angst, mytharc, light 'other' Summary: Autumn, New York City, 1953. A baseball player past his prime and a beautiful woman with a secret. Archive: link to www.geocities.com/prufrocks_love/moment.html Website: www.geocities.com/prufrocks_love/prupage.html Disclaimer: not mine; don't sue Silver spoons: Spooning: yes; Skinner's head: attached; Jenn: keep reading, you'll be fine; angst- o-meter: 5.9 out of 10; Snortameter: 7 out of 10 *~*~*~* A Moment in the Sun By prufrock's love The metal tray hit the floor, making Mulder jump and sending stainless steel instruments scattering, clattering loudly across the polished floor of the examination room. Nonplused, the overhead bulb continued to glare down, sullenly illuminating the scarlet splatters on the crumpled white shirt on his lap, and adding an atmospheric touch to an otherwise lackluster All Hallows Eve. Staring at the tangle of ruined sutures, swabs, and unnamed torture devices, Mulder reconsidered his decision to seek medical treatment: a nice, oozing, jagged scar might give his face some character. A little blood loss never killed anyone. "Idiot girl!" the red-faced doctor exploded at the nurse, not acknowledging he had been the one who had tipped the table over as he lumbered around. "Get a fresh tray and then clean this mess up! Christ, I can't stand incompetence." Never glancing at the patient, he ordered the nurse to call him when everything was ready to proceed; he would be in the lounge. Despite the trashcan beside the exam table, Dr. Zucker purposely dropped his gloves on the floor for her to pick up and teetered out through the swinging doors, taking his Napoleon Complex and his three-martini after-dinner snack with him. Mulder and his Oedipus Complex just sat, embarrassed to have been witness to such a scene and done nothing, hiding under the ice pack pressed to his forehead and watching his long legs dangling idly. The nurse used the toe of her white shoe to nudge a few gloves, sponges, and tweezer-looking things aside without comment, and then tilted his face to the light so she could see the small cut, sighing to herself. "Um, nurse?" "Yes, sir?" she replied, not seeming to notice how awkward he felt in his undershirt now that he was alone with her. "Is another doctor working tonight? Dr. Zucker seems to be, uh, well-" 'Drunk' would be the missing word. 'Asshole' would substitute in a pinch. "Dr. Zucker is usually-" She cleared her throat. "Do you want me to stitch this up so you can go? It looks worse than it is and your x-rays are fine." "Instead of a doctor? Can't you just get another doctor?" She leaned back against the cabinet, crossing her arms and alternating her weight between her feet. "Mr. um, Martin: it's one in the morning on a Sunday. I can get you some Jell-O and Aspirin and you can wait for Dr. Willis to come in at six or you can let me put three stitches in your head and be gone before whoever it is you're trying to avoid gets here. It's up to you. I'll tell Dr. Zucker he did it and he'll never know the difference." There didn't seem to be a choice, so he watched warily as she readied everything, flicking the syringe with her finger to get the bubbles out. No matter how many times he was cut or sewn for various injuries, and there had been many over the years, he still hated this part: the waitin', knowin' it's gonna hurt part. "Just a little prick, then it will be numb and I can put the stitches in. Come back here, big guy." He hadn't realized he was leaning away from her, eyeing the needle, until a warm hand took him by the shoulder and guided him back under the light. Mulder found himself eye-level with her breasts as she worked, which he made a great effort not to stare at. Apparently, he still wasn't staying where she placed him, since the nurse kept a firm grip on his chin while she cleaned and sewed one- handed. "So tell me, patient to nurse, what really happened to you, Mr. Martin," she began, trying to distract him from the big fishing hooks she was about to jab into his flesh, "Because this looks more like a blunt trauma than- What was that story you came up with?" "Slipped on some ice," he mumbled. "I thought that was pretty good, actually." She tossed a few used pieces of gauze in the trash and picked up the first suture. "Close your eyes, sir." He did, gladly. "First, it's October: there is no ice. Second, people generally fall backward when they slip, or else they have marks on their forearms where they catch themselves if they fall forward. And the angle is wrong. I'm guessing this is a-" She paused to readjust his head: without his homing nipple, he was drifting again, "Lead pipe, maybe? A pool cue?" "Do you promise you won't tell anyone?" "Promise. Stop squirming." "My kid accidentally hit me with a bat. Well, a bat he let go of. We were at the ballpark and I was trying to teach him to swing through instead of bunting. He got excited, swung hard, and let go, and it cracked me a good one. I waited for it to stop bleeding on its own, but it didn't, so I thought I should get checked out before I drove him home. Back to his mother's," Mulder added for clarity. "That's Slugger in the waiting room: the kid looking remorseful and uncoordinated." He heard her pulling the string to open a band-aid as she asked, "So what's so shameful about that? That's it. All done. See: the world didn't end. You can open your eyes now." "When it comes to my son, I like to keep things quiet, if I can; out of the papers, especially. He gets enough teasing as it is." Liking what he saw: her concerned face even with his, he smiled self-consciously, but the nurse didn't meet his gaze. She ran her thumb over the bandage to smooth it into place, paused to admire her handiwork, and then picked up his chart to make notes. "You get the same bill, regardless of whether the doctor or the nurse sews. You can pay as you leave if you don't want to give a billing address." "You honestly don't know who I am, do you?" he asked, immediately grimacing at himself for stooping to say that. It was a step away from handing her his baseball card with his phone number written on the front: pompous, unimaginative, and only effective on women who dotted their I's with little daisies. "Mr. Marty Martin- That's a lousy alias, by the way. Injured in- Do you want to have been mugged or won a bar brawl?" "Bar brawl. May I get dressed now?" She nodded, either not noticing or ignoring him watching her as she wrote. "Keep the wound dry, ice it to keep the swelling down, and come back to get the stitches out in two weeks. Stand outside the batting cage from now on or learn to dodge faster. If you start to get dizzy or confused or the wound looks infected, come back immediately." "I know a doctor who can take the stitches out. Is that okay?" "Fine. It was nice doing business with you, Mr. Not-Really-Martin." "Um, thanks, Nurse-" "Scully," she answered, walking out the door, leaving him fastening the top button of his ruined shirt, legs still dangling off the edge of the exam table, and noticing the room had warmed considerably. *~*~*~* It was always a toss-up: wear the Yankees cap and risk being recognized or wear any other hat like a normal adult and risk being recognized and called a traitor. After so many seasons in the blue and white uniform, Mulder generally went with the familiar Yankees cap. Besides, it did a fair job of hiding the bandage just above his left eyebrow as he slipped in through the ambulance bay. "Mr. Martin," Nurse Scully said, surprised to see him wandering around the vast ER again: in search of her, but she didn't know that. "I thought you had your own doctor: is something wrong?" Crap. Now this was starting to seem like a stupid idea. "I couldn't sleep, so I thought I'd come here and…" he trailed off, embarrassed. He'd actually been sitting across the street in his car for hours while he tried to work up his nerve. He had, too: gotten his nerve all worked up and then lost in somewhere between the curb and the exam room. He should go outside and look for it and get back to her in his next lifetime. "That's fine. We're quiet this morning. No one should bother you. Come with me." She gestured for him to follow her into one of the turquoise-tiled exam rooms, which Mulder did, twisting his hat in his hands and keeping his eyes open for his mislaid nerve. "Why would anyone bother me?" he asked, trying to sound innocent, thinking he would end up fixated on the one beautiful woman in New York who didn't recognize him. He hopped up on the exam table, trying to look athletic. Innocent and athletic: both tough at almost forty, but he had been a professional. She shrugged, tiptoeing to reach a bottle on the top shelf, snapped on a rubber glove, and poured some of the clear liquid into her gloved hand. Mulder's eyes widened: the last time someone had done that, it had been at his Army physical for WWII, and that examination hadn't turned out pleasantly at all. "These stitches aren't supposed to come out for another few days, but since you're here, it should probably be okay if the cut has healed." "I heal fast; I've had surgery on my knees a few times. What is that you're doing?" The smell was familiar, but Mulder couldn't place exactly what she was rubbing, though thankfully she was rubbing it on his forehead. "Baby oil. Whoever put this band-aid on put it over your eyebrow. If I just yank it off, part of your eyebrow is going to come with it and leave you lopsided. If I put baby oil on the bandage first, it comes off easier. Close your eyes in case it drips." "I put it on. Sorry; I guess I did it wrong." He took a deep breath, relaxing and deciding braving the Mercy ER again wasn't such a bad idea after all. New York Citywas full of unforgettably beautiful women who soon blended into a shallow, unforgettably beautiful blur, but this one was different. Touchable. Memorably real. He was certain there was something happening behind her blue eyes, but he was equally certain she'd never quite tell him what it was. She was silk-stockings-mysterious in a practical white- cotton-panties kind of way. She was deliciously contradictory in a world of banal, and as tempting as a broken cookie cooling on the baker's rack. And he was lonely. "I'll have to remember this trick: we tried batting practice again, and now my son has scrapes on both elbows." "How does one get batting injuries on one's elbows, Mr. Martin?" she asked, gently peeling off the band- aid, pursing her lips as she rubbed it to take away the sting, just in case. "One inherits absolutely none of his father's athleticism, Nurse Scully." *~*~*~* Yeah, this was low-key. Following a strange woman through the silent streets of the Bronx before dawn yelling 'nurse!' after her. This would never make the newspapers. It wasn't hard to keep pace with her, but Mulder couldn't get her to stop or listen to him until she reached the subway entrance and he had her trapped for a few seconds. "Go away! Haven't you had enough fun for one night?" She was so angry her cheeks were flushed and her eyes snapped blue fire at him. "I am sorry. Just go back to the hospital. I guarantee they will give you your job back." "Sure they will." Nurse Scully fished through her purse for a subway token, finally dumping it out on an empty bench in exasperation. A tube of lipstick escaped and rolled into the shadows and she didn't bother to retrieve it. "They will. Look: that doctor was out of line. You don't have to tolerate him talking to you like that." "You're right: I don't. But I know how to handle it and I don't need a hero. Thank you so much, Superman: you interfering just made it a hundred times worse. Not only do I not have a job, now I don't have a reference." "I swear to you the hospital will give you your job back. They'll fire that doctor and rehire you." "Why? Because you'll tell them to? I don't need some mobster who happens be nice to his kid to look out for me." She finally found the fifteen-cent subway token and fed it into the turnstile, leaving him standing on the other side. "Hey!" he yelled after her, his voice echoing through the tunnels over the roar of the train. "Hey! I'm not a mobster!" "Go to Hell, mister!" "I'm a ballplayer," he informed her as the doors of the subway car closed. "I played in the World Series ten times!" "I won nine of those!" Mulder told the back of the subway train. "I'm in the damn Hall of Fame!" "Shit!" he said to no one in particular. A whole city full of models and actresses and he gets hung up on one mouthy, hardheaded, redheaded nurse. *~*~*~* She better show up soon or Nurse Scully was going to find a remorseful Mulder-shaped icicle on her doorstep, he thought, glancing up from his seat on the cracked cement stoop and then huddling deeper into his winter coat. "You don't understand 'no' very well, do you, mister?" said the owner of the unhappy shadow suddenly looming over top of him, her head outlined golden by the sunrise. "I got your address from the hospital. And I brought your lipstick," he replied, his teeth chattering. Brilliant, Mulder; very smooth. Brace yourself, she'll be throwing herself into your arms any second. "Please: I don't want to bother you; I just don't want you to lose your job because of me." "It was a lousy job, anyway. And no man drives all the way from the Bronx to Brooklyn Heights out of the goodness of his heart or to return a dime store lipstick, Mr-" she paused expectantly. "Mulder. How did you know I drove?" She cocked her head in the direction of the out-of- place black Cadillac parked down the block, which he hadn't wanted her to notice, juggling the groceries she carried. "Are you a murderer, a rapist, or a mobster, Mr. Mulder?" He shook his head 'no.' "Married, insane, or a communist?" Another 'no.' "Then hold these groceries while I find my key and we'll call it even." She handed him two bulging brown paper sacks, balancing the third on her hip as she opened the security door. Not sure what was happening, or his role in it, Mulder followed her into the foyer and ended up holding all three bags while she went to the door of the first apartment. There was a brief exchange between she and the older woman who answered, and a sleeping girl in pajamas was passed into her arms. "Put those bags down," she told him over the child's blond head. "I'll get them. Thank you for going to so much trouble, Mr. Mulder, but it's really not necessary. We'll be fine." "I'll carry them up if you want. How could you manage three bags and her," he nodded to the limp child, "at the same time?" "The same way I've managed for years." She waited for him to move, then shrugged. "Suit yourself." "Which floor do you live on?" he asked when they reached the fourth set of steps and she hadn't slowed her pace. "The top. We have a view." The child stirred against her shoulder and blinked sleepily at Mulder. "So do I, but I also have an elevator." Nurse Scully seemed to have difficulty keeping track of things in her purse, because she shifted the groggy girl from hip to hip and then set her down on the mat while she hunted for her door key. Finally unlocking and putting her shoulder against the warped door to push it open, she herded a half-awake daughter inside the small apartment and then turned to Mulder to take the bags. "I'll carry them to the kitchen for you. Just leave the front door open." She glanced behind her at the racks of children's clothes and her own stockings, housedresses, and undergarments hung up to dry in the living room, probably decided he'd seen laundry before, and held open the door for him. He was setting the groceries on the table and trying to figure out another excuse, short of bleeding again, to hang around, when the little girl wandered in wearing her footy pajamas and began examining her mother's purchases. "Why couldn't you have woken up five flights of steps ago, Em?" her mother asked, her head deep in the icebox as she rearranged the bundles of her washed, starched and waiting-to-be-ironed nurses' uniforms to make room for her purchases. Mulder supposed yesterday must have been washday. "Who are you?" the child asked, a little fist digging into her eye as she stood precariously on a kitchen chair. "Mulder," he replied, leaning down so they were face to face. This was always a good step: making friends with a woman's kids. Not that he'd ever dated a woman with kids. And he wasn't really dating this woman; he was following her. Hell, he was still trying to make friends with his own kid, and he'd had fourteen years to do it. "Are you a nice man?" "I try to be." That was a very subjective question. She looked him up and down, her eyes full of serious four-year old thoughts and decided, "You can feed my cat." He supposed that was a vote of confidence. "Dry food, honey. I didn't buy tuna." A hand set a bowl of fish-shaped cat food morsels on the table and Mulder noted it lacked a wedding ring. "We're poor again? Why?" "Because we're so good at it," Scully replied, going to the living room to pull off her shoes and probably trying not to moan in pleasure. "It will be fine, Emily. Mr. Mulder-" she began as she unpinned her nurses' cap. "Let me buy you a drink." That was the first thing he could think of and it generally worked. "It's barely morning. Try again." Well, at least she hadn't thrown him out yet. "Breakfast?" Stretching out his fingers to help pet Emily's scruffy calico cat, Mulder asked, "Em, would you like to have breakfast? Aiello's will be open soon." The look on the woman's face actually made him flinch. Rooking in the kid hadn't been a good idea. "Aiello's is at Coney Island," Scully informed him, frowning, a little crease appearing between her eyebrows. "And by the time we get there, they will be open," he responded, feeling bold. "Let's hear the pitch, Mr. Mulder. Tall, dark, and handsome doesn't get very far with me. You can leave out the part about being obsessive and awkward around women, because I already know that." "My name is Fox Mulder," he began, having mastered that phrase early on in life. "I used to play ball, but I quit after last season. Um, I'm divorced, with a teenage son." He paused to consider for a second. "I think that's it. Not a mobster, communist, or murderer." She crossed her arms, focusing her gaze on him until he began to fidget. "An out-of-work, divorced ex-ballplayer?" She raised an eyebrow at him. "You make it sound so negative." *~*~*~* "You're late," Langly informed him tersely as Mulder burst through the office door, slightly out of breath. "We were about to start without you." "Feel free," Mulder replied, crossing immediately to the liquor cabinet, opening the wooden doors, and squatting down. His press agent, accountant, and attorney exchanged worried looks as Mulder rummaged through the glass bottles. He was sober now, after an extended retirement party last month spent at the bottom of an old-fashioned glass. Days that had once been occupied by baseball had quickly become filled with scotch and a few questionable women, but Mulder had been wise enough to find a wagon and stay on it when he saw where he was headed. As with many things in his life, Mulder had said very little about it, but everyone around him had breathed a sigh of relief when he stopped drinking and became himself again. Finally, it was Frohike, press agent extraordinaire, who said it: "It's ten-fifteen in the morning, Mulder; tell me you're hunting for canned orange juice." "I'm good, boys. Go ahead: I'm sure Byers is antsy that we're behind on his agenda for the meeting. Heaven knows my life isn't interesting enough that we need an agenda, but I'm sure he has one." Byers, Mulder's attorney for more than a decade, frowned. He did indeed have an agenda: typed up with mimeographed copies for everyone. "Item one: ex-wife," he said, raising his voice over the clinking of the liquor bottles. "Phoebe wants your son for Christmas and says you can have him for New Year's." "No," Mulder replied, now lining up rows of decanters on the rug as he cleaned out the cabinet in search of whatever he was searching for. "Will and I are going to Aspen with you; Phoebe already knows that." "That's what I thought. I'll deal with it. Item two: also ex-wife. Phoebe-" "We do this every week, Byers." Mulder interrupted, abandoning his search of the liquor cabinet and beginning to investigate the junk drawer of Langly's desk. "I'm tired of Phoebe being items one through five on the memorandum of my life. As long as I get to see Will, just give her whatever she wants. I'm not fighting anymore. Ah ha!" Mulder announced, triumphantly holding up the bottle of Rolaids. "I knew you'd have them. I'm not the only one with an ex-wife." Mulder flopped in the leather chair in the corner, making a face as a nasty taste of coffee mixing with stomach acid made its way up his throat. Swallowing several times, he shot the three men a puzzled look, as though he hadn't just made the most bizarre of announcements, and opened the antacids. "Move on. Item three " "You've eaten?" Frohike observed, familiar with the ulcer-acting-up expression. "You're telling us to give your ex-wife whatever she wants, and you're eating again? And you got your stitches out. I detect a new lady in your life. A nurse, maybe?" Mulder shrugged self-consciously. "He has it bad," Langly commented. "God help us all." "Well, it's about damn time." Frohike nodded in approval and picked up his pen, gesturing to Byers. "Item three." *~*~*~* Mulder was caught up in the impromptu game of street ball, vicariously reliving a few moments of glory, and didn't notice her watching him as she approached. He helped Emily swing and sent her running for first base, her oversized snow boots something of an impediment. Nurse Scully was a 'you'll grow into it' kind of mom. From the window of the apartment building, her babysitter applauded, nodding in approval. "You're like Em's cat, Mr. Mulder," came a woman's voice from the sidewalk. "I let you in once because you looked pitiful and now you keep showing up on my doorstep." He grinned, handing the bat off to one of the neighborhood boys, and walking to her eagerly. "Friday night. You said we could have dinner Friday night. It's Friday, it's almost night." He'd been here since four-thirty, just in case her definition of 'night' was early. What Mulder lacked in charm and tact, he made up for in doggedness, and he turned on his pleading Border Collie eyes for emphasis. "When you asked me at breakfast, I thought you meant next Friday." She was folding those arms again and he could feel a forehead crease coming on. His puppy-dog eyes weren't working, damn it. "Two meals; one day: I don't know, Mr. Mulder." He waited, adding a sad eyebrow as her gaze shifted between him and her daughter, who was waving proudly from first base. He'd known he meant next Friday, too. "I've been at work all afternoon. I'm not sure I'd be much fun this evening if I fall asleep in my soup." "Did you go back to the hospital?" Mulder asked, noting the stiff nurses' uniform peeking out from underneath her coat. "No. One of the agencies needed a private duty nurse. I called and they had a job for me this weekend; I thought I'd better take it now and sleep later. I'm sorry, but if I don't spend time with Emily tonight, I won't see her again until Sunday, and maybe not even then. I honesty didn't think you meant this Friday. Can I get a rain check?" "Bring her." She rubbed her temples, obviously very tired. "Thank you for your offer, but no. And thank you for being nice to her, but we're used to our lives the way they are. I don't want to confuse her by having men tramping in and out of her life. You and I can have dinner next week, if you still want to, but-" "My ex-wife left me when our son was a baby," Mulder replied, speaking so quickly his frosty breath didn't have time to dissipate in the cold air. "I was traveling constantly with the ball club, and she spends a lot of time in England: that's where she's from. Then the war, then more baseball, and before I knew it he was five, and then ten, and now a teenager I barely know. Every time I want to see him, it's a fight, and I don't know what to say when we are together: I mostly just buy him things. Your daughter Emily: I can talk to her. I don't mind her at all." "You don't play with people's lives, Mr. Mulder, especially not my daughter's." "I promise you I'm not playing," he replied, his voice low and soft, watching mesmerized as the season's first snowflakes landed on her eyelashes. *~*~*~* "Mrs. Osborne, this is Mulder. There was a message at the front desk that Mrs. Scully had called. Could I speak to her please?" "Of course; let me get her, Mr. Mulder; she's about to burst if she doesn't tell you her news soon, so just excuse her for being so forward," Emily's babysitter replied, as though women weren't beginning to call men left and right these days. Knowing what was coming, he held the receiver away from his ear as Mrs. Osborne bellowed, "DANA!" out her apartment door loud enough to carry up five floors. As usual, there were numerous clicks as everyone in her apartment building picked up their phones to listen on the party line. Mulder was, for reasons beyond him, was 'one of New York's most eligible bachelors:' an endorsement almost as deep as the society page it was printed on. Her neighbors tended to conjure up mental images of a tuxedo-clad Mulder sipping champagne on a balcony in Paris rather than a blue jean-clad Mulder, alone in the suite at The Plaza Hotel that he called 'home,' drinking flat ginger ale and picking at the hole in his right sock. "She's coming, Mr. Mulder." "Thank you." He stretched out on the sofa, watching the snow began to blanket Central Park outside his living room window as he waited. "Mr. Mulder," Scully said, slightly out of breath from having run down the stairs. "Hello." "Yeeesss, Nurse Scully." he replied, letting his head rest comfortably on the arm of the couch. "I understand you have news. We have an audience, though." There were a few guilty clicks as a couple of eves- droppers hung up, but their conversation was still being shared with the majority of Brooklyn Heights. "I got the job," she said, still breathless. "In pediatrics. Regular day shift: no midnights and no weekends. I'll even have insurance for Emily and I can be home for dinner every night." "That's wonderful!" Mulder replied, not as shocked as he tried to sound. He'd been watching her struggle through twenty-four and thirty-six hour shifts as a private duty nurse for dirty old men for a month now. Enough was enough. "When do you start?" "Monday. They want me as soon as possible." She paused, and Mulder heard her take a long, shaky breath. "Did you do this Mr. Mulder? I don't have any experience with pediatrics; I'm a trauma nurse." "So you think they shouldn't have hired you?" "No: I can do it. I just don't understand why the hospital would even interview me. A well-paying job close to home just falls in my lap: this has Fox Mulder-meddling written all over it." There was a long pause. This was a touchy subject; Dana Scully was as independent a woman as he'd ever met. Too independent, sometimes. "So I care enough to meddle," he finally admitted. "You deserve a break. If you can't do the job, you won't keep it. And no hospital is going to hire a nurse who isn't qualified." Another silence, so loud Mulder could hear the traffic from Seventh Avenue below him as he and everyone else listening in to their private neighborhood soap opera waited tensely. "You don't owe me anything," he added. "I called a friend and got you the interview, but you got the job on your own merits. Congratulations." "You can't buy me, Mr. Mulder." "I wasn't trying to," he responded meekly. Her neighbor's cuckoo clock on the second floor announced the hour and a teakettle and a toddler were both shushed while the neighborhood held its collective breath. "Thank you," he finally heard her exhale. *~*~*~* "You had a great career, Mulder. I saw every home run you ever hit at Yankee Stadium," he said, patting Mulder on the shoulder with a fatherly air. Mulder registered the older man as someone faintly familiar: maybe a regular guest at the hotel or a business acquaintance. He must be important or the headwaiter, familiar with Mulder's reclusiveness, would have already escorted him out of the restaurant. "You hit 131 triples and 389 doubles in 6,820 at bats," he continued, "I remember that and I forget my wife's birthday these days. Yes, you certainly had your moment in the sun. We're all very proud." Mulder forced a smile, wishing the man would just go the hell away and let then enjoy their dinner. It was wonderful, at thirty-nine years old, to be talked about in the past tense, as though his life had ended when he stepped off the ball field. And it was 6,821 at-bats. "Tough to keep up with those nineteen-year old kids, isn't it?" Mulder received a few more sympathetic pats as he begin to grit his teeth. "No one blames you; you're a legend, Mulder. And you quit while you were ahead." They'd never been out without Emily, and fans were a little more reluctant to approach 'a family' having hotdogs. This was supposed to be their first 'big grownup date,' as Em called it, but it meant Scully had to endure the full brunt of the adoring public for the first time. Mulder had chosen The Oak Room, one of the restaurants in The Plaza, hoping this would be a gentle introduction into the spotlight for her. In the dark, almost medieval atmosphere, New York's elite old-boys-club shaped history while their respective, decorative wives cast sideways glances and whispered over their cocktails, eyeing the new competition. Taking a long drag off his cigarette, the gentleman continued, "Life goes on, though. It's good to see you have new interests." He gestured to Scully, who was staring at her lap, red-faced. "Lovely." "If you will excuse us," Mulder growled, laying his knife across the back of his plate, standing, and squaring his shoulders. He was fair game; Scully was not. Catching their waiter's eye, he mouthed 'back room' and offered his hand to Scully. His suite upstairs would be much nicer than the employees' dining room, but he didn't want Scully to get the wrong idea about his intentions, especially since she was still antsy about his role in her new job. Two waiters appeared instantaneously, picking up their plates and glasses without comment and heading to the back of the restaurant. "My apologies, Mr. Mulder: I didn't mean to intrude," the smoking man drawled, not looking the least bit apologetic. "Please, you and Miss Scully stay." "You're not intruding. We were just leaving. Have a nice evening," he managed. This man must know Scully. He knew her name, but Scully didn't seem too fond of him. "Have a nice evening," the man replied, stubbing out his cigarette in their previously unused ashtray and reaching inside his expensive suit coat for another, watching as Mulder hurried Scully away. The kitchen staff were used to Mulder getting tired of living on room service and wandering down to eat with them, but they weren't quite sure how to react to Scully, assuming she was a starlet or a model. They had her wait while the old magazines and ashtrays were cleared away and a white tablecloth was unfurled over the battered card table. As a final touch, the head chef appeared with a bud vase containing a single white rose and Scully's quiet smile reappeared. "I am so sorry," Mulder apologized, pulling out the metal folding chair for her. "He doesn't mean any harm. People don't even think about what they're saying." "It's okay," she replied, trying to arrange her full silk skirt so it didn't drag on the less-than- spotless floor. "Our dates so far have been adventures." "Adventures?" He rested his hand tentatively on top of hers on the table. "You spend your evenings with an over-the-hill, divorced ballplayer and you think that's an adventure?" "It suits me," she replied, casually dropping her napkin on her lap, then looked up at him with those shining eyes. A little flustered, he stuttered, "That's, that's good," before he lost the power of intelligent speech and just kissed her. Back. Kissed her back. *~*~*~* "Hey, Dad," William said, tossing his book bag into the back seat and slamming the passenger-side door so hard the window rattled. "Mother's gonna kill you: it's not Friday yet." Mulder decided it wasn't worth it to tell him not to slam doors. "I just wanted to talk to you. About a few things. I already called your mother; it's okay. You want to get a milkshake?" He glanced in the rearview mirror and then eased the car back onto Joralemon Street, driving slowly as the other children streamed out of the elite prep school and into waiting cars. "There's a soda shop a few blocks over: I'd rather get a cup of coffee." Switching lanes, Mulder asked, "When did you start drinking coffee?" "Is this about why you married my mother? She said that's why you left school to play ball; because she got knocked up and baseball paid the bills. Is that what you wanted to talk about, because I already know all about it." Will was nothing if not direct. "Mother's been on a rant this week," he added. "Hey! Honk the horn; I know this girl!" Mulder felt his ulcer awakening as William leaned precariously out the car window to flirt at the stoplight. Trying not to be a pervert, Mulder checked his son's latest interest out of the corner of his eye: tall, blonde, seventeen, and bright as a burnt-out light bulb: Will definitely had a type. "You know none of that is your fault, don't you, Will? William, can you sit back down and roll up the window, please? If you want to talk about this, then act like it. What happened between your mother and me is not your fault. Both of us love you very much." Sighing, the boy threw himself down in the seat, sprawling the too-long legs and too-big feet he hadn't yet grown into and tilting the mirror to check his hair. "I know that. Don't get all hyped up about it; your ulcer will start bothering you. And Mother wants me to ask you if she can take me to London with her for the summer. She says I can't stay with you all three months because you're an incompetent bum." The incompetent bum who'd been paying her bills since the late 1930's, but Phoebe probably left that part out of her lectures. "And what are you supposed to tell her when she asks you to tell me things, Will?" "To have her attorney call your attorney and not to put me in the middle," he rattled off, making his 'this is stupid' face. "I don't really listen to her. It's always the same speech anyway." "How in the world did you end up this normal, son?" "Maybe because my Dad's a living legend," William replied in his British accent, grinning at him around a mouthful of braces. Mulder grinned back. "Nah. That can't be it." *~*~*~* "You're not supposed to be drinking that," William informed him, as though Mulder didn't know that. "I'm not drinking it; I'm smelling it." He had to put the cup of coffee down to sign autographs for three giggling teenage girls while Will rolled his eyes, looking too much like his mother. "So what was the girl's name on the corner: the one in the red coat? She seemed, uh, interesting." "That is not why you picked me up today," the boy responded, pouring so much sugar into his coffee that Mulder's tongue started to salivate in protest. Clearly, William wanted to appear he enjoyed drinking coffee much more than he actually enjoyed drinking coffee. "Spill it. Is this about the woman in the newspaper pictures with you? Mother's already checked her out, you know. Dana Scully, right?" Lovely. He added a little more cream to his own cup. Even if he couldn't drink it, Mulder found it comforting to have his coffee flavored correctly. "That's right: Dana Scully. I'd like you to meet her. And," He swallowed, "I'd like to ask her to come to the Byers' house in Aspen with us for Christmas." "You're that serious about her?" Like Scully, Mulder didn't waltz people in and out of his son's life, so this was a first. He nodded, focusing on thoroughly stirring his coffee. "I'm that serious." "The paper says you've only been seeing her a few months." That hit a nerve: the pinched one connecting his heart and conscience. "You don't need to keep track of your father through the society pages. Just pick up the phone and call me, Will." He tapped his spoon harder than necessary on the rim of his mug and the soda jerk appeared, thinking Mulder wanted something. "I'd love to talk to you on a weekday. Just about whatever: school, movies, girlfriends. Whatever you want to talk about." "Mother makes it-" William started and then stopped, tearing his napkin to bits as the counter boy hovered. "It's hard to call you from Mother's apartment. It causes problems." "I'm sorry," Mulder mumbled, wondering where his son learned such a messy habit and began to shred his own paper napkin while he looked for a straw to gnaw on. Will, recovering faster, asked lightly, "So tell me: what isn't in the papers about Dana Scully?" "Um, she has beautiful red hair; you can't tell that in black and white. Well, neither of us could tell anyway, but she does. She was the nurse that patched up my head at Halloween and I've been seeing her since then." He stirred his coffee thoughtfully, trying to gauge the boy's reaction. "She has a young daughter named 'Emily.' We've been keeping that out of the papers." Will nodded, understanding. That was one of the few restrictions his father placed on the press: taking pictures of his son or hounding him when they were in public together was not allowed. Any reporter or photographer who forgot that didn't stay employed very long. "Widowed or divorced?" Mulder raised his eyebrows. "She was an Army nurse until her daughter came, so I assume her husband died in Korea. I've never asked her. I'm sure it's not an easy subject for her to talk about. He must have died when Emily was a baby; Em doesn't seem to remember him at all. They've probably been alone for a long time." "You smile when you talk about her. Do you know that?" Mulder actually blushed, sloshing his coffee over the side of the mug. "Sure: bring her. Them. We need more people who can't ski. You wanna help me with my history homework?" his son asked, saving him from sinking under the table in embarrassment. "It's British history and I hear you went to Oxford." *~*~*~* "Does it make me a bad father to occasionally think my son is insane?" Mulder asked her, tugging self- consciously at his borrowed black turtleneck as he returned to his place on the couch beside her. Will had insisted he couldn't wear an undershirt with it and he felt half-naked. "Or is that me going insane?" "Is that still Bill Haley he's playing or that other man?" Scully said, shifting comfortably as he wrapped an arm around her shoulders. "I think that's a clear sign of insanity for both of you: him for buying the rock-n-roll records and you for letting him play them." "I have 'Rock Around the Clock' and 'Shake, Rattle, and Roll' permanently burned into my brain, taking up space that could be used for Ella Fitzgerald and Count Basie," Mulder sighed. William had brought his new 45's to Aspen with them and had been playing his Hi-Fi at top volume for the non-skiers for the last two hours. "He's sane," he decided. "Probably ruining his life by listening to that music and going to end up hooked on marijuana and riding motorcycles, but sane at the moment." "What's with the snappy outfit?" Scully asked, offering him a sip of her tea. "It's Will's. He says it makes me look like a beatnik." Mulder tilted his head to whisper in her ear, "I don't know what a beatnik is." "I think it's a good thing," she replied, squirming adorably as he nuzzled her neck. "Uummm. I hope so. This," Mulder tilted her head back to access her pale throat, "This is a good thing. I like this, Scully: just being with you." There was the sound of a man clearing his throat as Mulder's attorney and Susanne came in from the slopes. Their twin daughters and Emily followed them, cheeks red from the cold and looking like Indian warriors with the stripes of zinc oxide Scully had painted on them against the winter sun. It said something about the sum of his life, Mulder thought, at forty years old, to spend Christmas with, excepting Scully and her daughter, people he paid. Even his son, in a way, was bought and paid for by major league baseball. And worth every penny. Scully, as he watched her wipe up the new puddles and peel her daughter out of her snowsuit, was clearly not for sale, though. Mulder just watched, sipping his borrowed tea, thinking this was very pleasant: just being together with friends and family in front of a warm fire. It was very pleasant, very normal, and very unfamiliar and welcome territory. *~*~*~* "Is everything okay?" Mulder asked, as Scully quietly carried Emily into the kitchen, both of them wearing their pajamas. "Another bad dream?" Scully paused, scrutinizing him. She obviously didn't like him either knowing about or commenting on her nightmares. He'd been up late the previous night and heard her cry out, but been hesitant to wake her, uncertain as to how she would react to finding him in her bedroom. "I heard you last night," he finally said, and Scully looked away. "We're fine; just getting something to drink. Why are you still up?" "My roomy says he can't sleep without someone called 'Elvis' playing on the Hi-Fi. Again and again and again. It was okay the first twenty times, then the sofa started to call. Is Emily feeling okay?" "I think she's just overdone it: too much excitement this weekend and now she can't relax. Can you hold her while I find a cup?" Scully probably had no idea how erotic it was: to be so close to her in the moonlight while wearing nothing but a few layers of cotton as he took the child from her. There were plenty of girls that 'did', but it was the ones who 'didn't' who were still sexy padding around a kitchen in their slippers at four in the morning searching for the milk. The girls who 'did,' in Mulder's experience: those needed some lace or satin or at least a few strong drinks to dull his brain first. "Look out there, Em," he told her, carrying the child to the kitchen window to see the lights on the mountain so she wouldn't notice that 'Santa' and his attorney had already visited the living room. "Santa must be getting close. He can't come until you're asleep." Scully found the bottle of milk, pronounced it drinkable, and poured a few swallows. As the girl finished it, Mulder wiped her chin and asked, "You think maybe you can sleep now so Santa can come?" Emily felt she possibly could, with a story, so he carried her down the hall to Scully's room, her blue eyes finally getting heavy as he reached the 'moon on the breast of the new-fallen snow' part for the fourth time. By the time Santa had 'a little round belly that shook like a bowl full of jelly,' or something to that effect, she was out cold. "If you're trying to impress me, you've done it," Scully said, coming up behind him as he tucked the blankets over Emily. "I'd about had it with her." He was a little surprised: the word 'competent' always came to mind when he thought of Scully-as-a- mother. She made taking care of her daughter alone look effortless, although it had to be anything but. It made Mulder feel better to know he wasn't the only one who occasionally thought he was failing the parenthood test. "You can't be too impressed. You've just spent three days with my son. That should scare any woman away." "I don't scare easily." "Obviously not," he replied, finding a waist under her cotton pajamas and pulling her to him as they watched Emily sleeping. "You're doing an amazing job with her. But then," he kissed the nape of her neck, searching with his lips until he found her pulse and then pressing, feeling it quicken, "You're pretty amazing yourself. You shouldn't have to raise her alone." Scully turned to face him, letting him lead her the few steps into the hallway, just in case Emily awoke. "And you're wonderful with Will." He was speaking between kisses now, his mouth insisting hers open as trembling, eager arms went around his neck. "And you're wonderful with me." His pajama bottoms were thin and she was pressed against him; Scully pulled back within a few seconds, his cue to stop. This time, though, as she moved away, he moved closer, instinctively keeping the contact. "Stop, Mulder. This isn't right." "Yes, it is. It's very right. And I'll stop." He exhaled, trying to regain control as he rested his forehead against hers. Scully was correct; they needed to wait. "I will stop," Mulder repeated, more as a command to himself than as an assurance to her. "Say you'll marry me, Scully: this is what's right. Us. Together. It feels more right than anything I've ever felt in my life." Realizing what he'd said, he punctuated his proposal by pulling her face to his, fingers lost in her hair, and embracing her with a hungry intensity that probably frightened her. It frightened him: burning the way dry kindling became engulfed before anyone even realized it was smoldering. He'd never proposed to a woman of his own free will Before: more like a 'guess we hafta get married, huh?' He and William had even practiced earlier, their conversation concealed by five-dozen repetitions of "That's All Right Little Mama" that afternoon. His son, not old enough to drive yet, was better at smooth talking than Mulder was. The part that came after smooth talking, Mulder had had a few more years to learn, and he was willing to just skip to that and finalize the details afterward. He thought for a few wonderful moments that she was actually going to let him do this, his groin getting ahead of his brain. As his left hand covered her breast and his right unbuttoned her top, Scully brought her arms up and forcefully pushed him away. "Sorry," he apologized, trying to catch his breath. "Sorry, Scully. I'm sorry." She wrapped her white cotton top around her as though it was a robe and leaned back against the wall of the hallway, not looking at him. "Scully, look at me." She glanced up, sniffing. "I do mean it. You said it's wrong to play with people's lives and I'm not playing. This isn't a game to me. You're not a game or something that I can win, only lose." Christ, he sounded like a complete idiot. "Come here." When she didn't move, he took her by the hand and led her to the Christmas tree, sitting amidst the new bicycles and train sets he and Byers had assembled earlier. "This is Will's idea. In case you still think I'm only trying to seduce you, you should know I don't usually ask my son for advice." He searched under the tree until he found two small boxes he'd brought from Manhattan. Scully wiped her eyes, trying to figure out what he was talking about. "I was going to do this when we opened presents in a few hours, but now seems fine. These are pearl earrings. I thought they were pretty," he said, holding up one of the velvet boxes. "And this one is a ring; my grandmother's. I do mean it, Scully. Pick what you want." *~*~*~* "Dad?" William asked, stirring in his twin bed on the far side of the room they shared as his father entered. There was a muted sound as a small box was hurled into a pile of dirty clothes by a right arm attached to a living legend and pictured in the damn Hall of Fame. "Go to sleep, Will." "Did you ask her?" "Go to sleep! Damn it, I need a drink." "No you don't," Will replied, much too loudly, as he sat up in bed, prepared to intervene if his father stepped toward the liquor cabinet. "You're right: no, I don't," Mulder said, sitting down hard on his bed and burying his face in his hands. "Did you ask her? What did she say?" Laying back, his feet still on the floor on one side of the bed as his head hung back off the other, he took one of those deep, calming breaths his doctor was always harping on him about. He'd had a fastball hit him square in the chest once, and it felt exactly the same. The doctor had told him to take deep breaths then, too, and it never helped one damn bit. "She said 'no.'" *~*~*~* Emily was amusing herself in the front seat between Mulder and Scully by having little conversations with her new Mr. Potato Head as they drove back from North Beach Airport. Will was still sprawled across the backseat and making loud, disappointed sighing noises. Mulder, trying not to lose his temper with the rush of holiday drivers as he navigated traffic, asked his son for about the fifteenth time, "Will, you didn't really expect me to buy you a car, did you? Next year, when you're old enough to drive, we'll see." The only reply was another sigh, some muttering, and a sharp knee hitting Mulder's back through the seat as William rearranged himself: probably not an accident. "I'll teach you to drive this summer while your Mother's away and then you can pick out the car you want, within reason, for next Christmas," Mulder offered, hating both the idea that he was ruining his son's holiday and that he was getting sucked into this stupid teenage game. He braked suddenly to avoid a pack of shoppers delirious with fresh kill from Macy's and threw out an arm to stop Emily from hitting the dash. "I'm not buying you a car until you're old enough to drive. I don't know where you got that idea, but it's not going to happen! Pout all you want!" "Mother will buy it for me!" Will retorted. "She said I could have it!" Mulder managed to keep his mouth shut, his knuckles white on the steering wheel. "You're just being mean!" Will shouted, opening the door to get out as Mulder waited for a light to change. "I hate you!" "Don't you dare get out here. It's another three blocks," Mulder ordered, as though Will hadn't spent almost a decade of his life in Manhattan and didn't know it was another three blocks. "Since I don't have a car, I'll just walk!" Will punctuated his dramatic protest by slamming the door and stalking off, looking as dignified as any fourteen, almost-fifteen-year old wearing pink socks and cuffed blue jeans possibly could. Mulder angrily rolled down his window and yelled, "William!" after him, but his son kept walking. Reaching down to retrieve Mr. Potato Head's plastic red lips from the floorboards for Emily, Scully gave him a look located somewhere between sympathetic and amused. "It's no wonder you said 'no,'" he said, watching Will's dark head bobbing through the crowd. "What in the world am I doing wrong?" "Pick a holiday and give him a car key and an I.O.U. redeemable on his sixteenth birthday, maybe even a picture of the car. He wants a Thunderbird, right? Make it conditional on his getting his license. That way he knows he'll get it and he can brag, but you can stall until he matures enough to be driving." Wide-eyed, Mulder replied, "How do you know to do that?" "You weren't around very much when he was a toddler, were you?" Scully said, helping Emily climb over the seat into the back so she could stretch out after their long flight. "Try doing all your shopping with a two-year old and you'll learn these tricks. I doubt teenagers are any different." "I wonder how I would get a key for next year's model? I'll call the dealership after I drop you off." "No, you've already missed your chance. If you do it now, you'll be giving in to his tantrum." "New Year's? A New Year's gift?" "You try so hard, don't you, Mulder?" "I guess I do," he said, pulling into a parking space in front of Phoebe's building to wait and make sure Will arrived safely. "I have a lot to make up for." *~*~*~* He glanced in the rearview mirror to check that Emily was really asleep under his coat in the backseat and not just pretending, and then said quietly, "We had to get married." Scully had been watching the fog roll off the river as they sat stuck in a traffic jam on the Brooklyn Bridge, and looked back at him quickly. "I was thinking on the plane ride home that you don't know much about me, and maybe that's why you said 'no.' My ex-wife would be a good place to start." "I want to know whatever you want to tell me." He couldn't tell of she was completely horrified or just waiting to hear the whole story. It wasn't that exciting a tale. "I had a bad week, had too much to drink, and Phoebe was just there that night. It just happened. I was twenty-three; I'd never-" He stopped, taking a breath and trying for the less explicit version. "I tried taking her home to meet my parents once, right after we were married, but they were just horrified. 'Oxford' my mother kept saying; how could I have thrown away Oxford. My father was Boston blue blood at it's best, and this was the last straw for him I had a sister who disappeared and he always blamed me. It didn't matter that we never found out what happened to Samantha, it was still my fault, according to him. Marrying Phoebe was just the final screw-up in his book. My mother has seen Will, once, but my father died last year without ever meeting him. He never even acknowledged that he exists. Phoebe's pretty, and she can be lots of fun, but she's not- She was a waitress at the pub, and she had a bad reputation, even then. My parents didn't miss that. They thought I should have just walked away." "Why didn't you?" It was a valid question; nice boys didn't marry bad girls, not matter what. He just shrugged, moving the confession along, not wanting to admit how dazzled he'd been at the idea of having a family of his own. A normal family, where the mother spoke to the children and the father came home, and stayed sober, at night. "My original plan was to work part-time and finish graduate school. I only had a few more months, and the FBI had already offered me a job, but that just wasn't going to happen once my father refused to help. So I came home: to New York instead of Boston so my parents wouldn't be embarrassed in front of their friends. When Will was three months old, Phoebe had enough, left me, and took Will back to England with her for about six years. I spent about five of those years certain she was going to come back any day." He took a nervous breath. "The minor leagues were having open tryouts and they were willing to pay me more than I was making loading trucks at the docks. I spent a month playing Class A ball for New York-Penn before the Yankees made me an offer. I was their star hitter and centerfield for more than a decade until, like the man at the restaurant said, I couldn't keep up with the nineteen- year old kids anymore. I can still throw and hit, but my knees have just had too much abuse over the years. That's why I don't ski anymore. I didn't want to make a fool of myself, so I quit while I was still ahead." There was a long silence in the car as impatient horns blared mindlessly around them on the bridge: drivers furious at having their lives interrupted. "End of story, Scully. Please don't get out of the car and start walking yet. We're still a long way from your apartment and it's cold." To his surprise, he saw tears streaming down her face. "Scully?" "Was it worth it: not walking away? Not playing by everyone's rules?" "I never looked back," Mulder said, pulling her across the seat so she sat beside him, stroking her cheek anxiously with his fingertips. "At least, I try not to. It was the right thing for me. How can I miss a life I'll never know? If I would have told Phoebe tough luck, finished school, and gone to work for Hoover, I would never have heard sixty-seven thousand fans cheering when I walked up to bat for the final game of the World Series last year. I hit my three hundred and sixty-first, and last, home run over the wall at Yankee Stadium and my son saw it. Yes, I think it was worth it." *~*~*~* "Are you sure you don't want to go up on the roof with everyone else for the fireworks?" Mulder asked as they stepped off the elevator, Scully swaying against him in her high heels, giving him an excuse to keep an arm around her waist. "The band is even on the roof." "I want to see this view you've been bragging about for months," Scully replied. "In the dark?" he answered huskily, resting his hands on her hips, stroking the velvet fabric as he leaned his face close to hers. "You just wanted to ride my elevator." Scully nodded, laughing softly as they embraced in the foyer, glad to finally be away from photographers and prying eyes in the ballroom. Caught up in exploring the textures and smells of her hair and mouth and skin, the first of the fireworks exploded before Mulder noticed how much time had passed. "Balcony." He slipped his tuxedo jacket over her bare shoulders before pushing open the glass doors to the terrace. Not even noticing the pyrotechnics, they began their New Year's kiss, or continued the one from last year, as the blue and red stars exploded over Central Park. "Happy New Year." "Happy New Year," she replied from just behind his right ear as her lips moved across his skin, the sensation catching him off guard. This woman had no idea what she did to him, and that made it even worse. "Come inside before you freeze," he whispered a few minutes later, although neither of them was in danger of being cold. She stayed close to him, kissing, touching, keeping hold of his hand as he backed into the apartment. He reached behind her to slide the door closed, then pressed her against the glass, blood singing in his ears when she didn't object. He kept waiting for Scully to tell him to stop, but she didn't, and, although he hadn't had any alcohol in months, it made him feel a little drunk to know she wanted this. Bedroom, Mulder decided. They weren't two teenagers who had to fumble awkwardly on the couch. "You tell me when to stop," he told her, "We go as far as you want and no further, I promise." "I don't want you to stop," Scully said, sitting, then watching him as she lay back, still fully dressed, the primary colors of the fireworks outside the window making patterns on her white shoulders. "I want you to make love to me." "Then marry me, Scully," Mulder whispered, running his fingers lightly over the swell of her breast as he joined her. "Make this right." Christ, it was incredible just to see her laying across his bed, waiting for him, watching him. There had to be a way to have this happen every night. "Please, Scully. I don't want to wake up tomorrow knowing I've done something wrong." "Make love to me, Mulder," she repeated, wrapping her arms around his neck and pulling his face down to hers. *~*~*~* "I can't stay," she murmured, nuzzling the underside of his neck like a sleepy kitten. Of course not: God forbid two adults who love each other get to spend an entire night together. People would talk. "I'll drive you home. Just stay with me for a little bit: no one will notice with the party still going." Mulder kissed the top the tousled head resting on his shoulder, trying to arrange his thoughts in a straight line. "Why did you let me do that, Scully?" "Why did you do it, Mulder?" "I think you know that." Perhaps she had misunderstood all hundred and fifty-two times he'd told Scully he loved her since leading her into his bedroom. Or the fourteen times he'd asked her to marry him, including one especially suave 'if you get pregnant, then you'll have to,' offer. "I can't seem to have you any other way." Ah: there was the guilt. He brought his wrist up so he could see his watch in the moonlight. Almost ten minutes post-coitus to guilt and Mulder estimated another seven minutes until his ulcer awoke. "What is it, Scully? Phoebe got in trouble, yes, but- I was young; I'm not like that. Yes, there have been women, especially right after I quit playing ball and I was drinking, but I don't go around doing this: seducing nice girls. Is it Will? That I'm not a doctor or a lawyer? That I'm older than you are? That my mother's family is Jewish? Do you not want me raising Emily?" Mulder stared at the ceiling, listening to the party-goers still ringing in the new year on the roof above them. "Or do you just not love me?" She shifted closer to him, her breath warming the skin at the base of his throat as she toyed with the coarse hair on his chest. "Of course I love you." "Then what is it? Something about you? Whatever it is, I don't care. You've met my press agent. Frohike can make anything in your past vanish. He always says I'm too boring for his talents. Are you divorced? I always thought your husband had died, but-" Mulder's thoughts finally managed to arrange themselves single- file. "Did he just leave you? Are you still married?" That would make sense: no alimony, child support, or widow's pension. The midnight shift in the ER probably paid slightly more and Mercy, a Catholic hospital, would be sympathetic and willing to hire- "No, I've never been married." Mulder was busy congratulating himself on his brilliant intuition and didn't process her words until he realized he wasn't breathing. "I didn't do anything wrong, Mulder." Her voice was trembling. "I'm sure you didn't, honey," he got his mouth to say, trailing his fingers up and down her bare back as the rest of his body lay paralyzed. "I'm sure you didn't." "I did all the right things: I went to the home for unwed mothers. I didn't have a choice: the Army discharged me and I couldn't find a job in that condition. And I certainly couldn't go home to my parents. When she came, though, I just couldn't leave her. I kept her and I started over." Although he could feel her starting to sob, Mulder just pulled her closer, not trusting himself to speak or look at her. "I never lied to you; I never lied to anyone. People just assume I'm a widow, but when hospitals check my references, they find out why I was discharged from the military and that I wasn't married." "Why didn't he marry you?" "Oh, it doesn't matter, Mulder." She sniffed, starting to sit up. "Let go of me so I can leave." "If I wanted you to leave, I'd let go of you." Decision made. He'd have to pay Frohike overtime to make this go away, but Dana Scully would become a war widow for anyone who cared to look. "I just want to know what happened. Was Emily's father killed in the war? Was he already married? Did one of the officers force-" "I don't know who her father is!" She blurted out, jerking out of his grasp and turning her back to him in the bed. "There was no one to marry because I have no idea who her father is." Scully wrapped the sheet around her, picked up her evening dress and underclothes from the floor, and hurried into the bathroom. After the door closed, Mulder heard her lock it. By the time she emerged, he'd pulled on his tuxedo trousers and found the ring in the pocket where he'd put it earlier, just in case. He was sitting at the bottom of the bed, resting his face in his hands, and telling himself this wasn't real. Scully was just not like that; he'd just been with her and she wasn't like that. "Instead of sending me to Korea, the Army assigned me to an underground base in the middle of the Nevada desert. They were doing secret experiments with technology like I'd never seen, but I was proud to do my part. Except that my part was a joke: they had me maintaining medical records and storing tissue samples; I never laid a finger on a live person. Within a few months I started getting sick and fainting and the doctor said I was going to have a baby. There were about a dozen young nurses and secretaries and clerks on the base, and we all found out we were expecting. I can't speak for the others, but I didn't do anything to get that way. They gave up their babies and I didn't. I couldn't, even when the men from the base insisted. I don't expect you to believe me. I don't expect you to ever speak to me again if you pass me on the street, but I wanted you to know the truth. I did what was right for me." "Women do not just get in trouble without doing something to get that way, Scully. There is no secret base underground where the government is using women as brood mares. This is the United States, for God's sake, not Nazi Germany. I fought for our Government. I got shot for our government. I've met President Eisenhower! There is no big baby conspiracy, honey." "Of course, Mulder. It all sounds so silly. Of course, I would make up a story like that instead of just picking out a late husband off a tombstone." "Scully," he managed to get out, not raising his face. "Just don't go. I don't care what happened, just don't leave. I can fix this." "You don't understand, Mulder: there's nothing wrong with me. There's nothing wrong with my daughter. You're welcome to love us, but we don't need you to fix us. We aren't broken." Then there was the rapid clicking of unsteady stiletto heels across the expanse of his penthouse suite and the sound of his front door opening and closing softly. As Mulder sat shaking on the edge of the rumpled bed, the party ringing in 1954 on the roof above him was still going strong. *~*~*~* He hung up the phone, telling himself it was an appropriate compromise: he'd called room service for a breakfast that didn't include vodka on his orange juice, but he was having coffee, damn it. After this long a night, he deserved coffee. Shower: Mulder had been avoiding it, not wanting to wash the traces of her away. Shower, and then go after her and hope it wasn't too late. Stand in the street outside her building and throw rocks at the window until she came out if he had to, but he was going to make this right. If she hadn't gone to bed with him last night, he would never have believed her, never even have thought to check the story. Women did not just miraculously conceive. Scully, though: she'd asked him if that was supposed to happen, that nice feeling like her insides had sneezed. He'd laughed, at the time thinking she was joking, and told her sometimes it happened twice. The more he thought about it, the more the wheels had started to turn. She really hadn't ever been with a man before. Which meant he had a few more things to apologize for. About two in the morning he'd managed to move and call Frohike, repeating what Scully had said. By six, Frohike had called back to report that there was indeed a Top Secret part of Nellis Air Force Base in Nevada called Area 51. One near where there were reports of a UFO crashing a few years ago, he'd said, causing Mulder to laugh out loud. Aliens; there's no such thing as space aliens. More importantly, and rationally, there was a home for unwed mothers conveniently close by where young women could have and leave their babies. He was still working the phones, Frohike told him, but they couldn't find any record of those children ever being adopted. They just vanished. "You mean she's telling the truth? How in the world do you get a woman to have a baby without, uh-" Frohike enlightened him in graphic detail until Mulder asked him to stop out of basic decency. "But why? Why create illegitimate children? It's not like there's a shortage." Continuing the German experiments, Frohike speculated. Maybe at attempt to create a superior human. All the mothers were bright, attractive, healthy young women who should have been sent to Korea instead of stateside. "There's something else, Mulder: my sources are mentioning your name. Yours and Samantha's, both." "I'm not adopted," he immediately replied, resenting even the implication. "Neither of us are; I remember Sam being born. The government had just transferred my father and we had to move. I remember my mother trying to pack all by herself while she was so big with Samantha." "No, not under the adoption records, just as two of the people they tracked. There are other names: athletes, artists, scientists, politicians, and professors. Didn't you ever wonder how you could take up professional baseball at twenty-three years old and make twenty-five thousand dollars your first year? Maybe you're somehow genetically predisposed to the game." "Frohike," Mulder had said, "Have you been into the booze again? Why in the hell would anyone want to breed ballplayers?" "Maybe you weren't supposed to be a ballplayer." That had taken a full hour to digest. Mulder had then placed a call to a very unhappy Byers, still on vacation in Aspen and sound asleep, and ordered him to get his hands on these records immediately: Emily, Samantha, Scully, him. He wanted to know what the hell the government was doing to people. He'd heard his attorney crack his neck, yawn, and ask from whom exactly he was supposed to subpoena these documents? "Try Hoover," Mulder had told him, "Maybe Eisenhower. Or the Martians. Beats me; just get them." Lucy usually knocked when she brought up meals, but maybe she was taking New Year's Day off. "Thank you," he called to whoever had come in the front door as he fastened his pants. There was no response, and Mulder assumed he was getting the silent treatment from the kitchen staff for ordering a forbidden cup of coffee. He suspected a conspiracy between his doctor and the chef. Frohike and his wild theories were starting to rub off on him. Alien babies. That's it: Emily was a Martian baby. Sure: and men would be walking on the moon one day soon. He smirked and tossed his towel at the hook on the back of the bathroom door. Shirtless and hair still damp, he padded barefooted into the kitchen, slipping the ring into his pocket, and intending to quickly down his coffee and toast before he left to do whatever it was he was going to do. Beg, probably. "Goodness, Fox; forty suits you well," came a voice with a clipped cockney accent as Phoebe looked him up and down. "The years are kind to you." "How did you get in here?" "I used a key." She held up Will's, looking victorious. His throat tightened. "Is Will okay?" Frohike had him too paranoid to see straight. Phoebe shrugged, and did a walkthrough of his rooms as though she was Queen of Sheba, pausing to peer into the master bedroom. "Bed looks well- used. I recall you preferring the couch. Was she here last night?" He'd actually begun preferring the couch when Phoebe was briefly the one he was expected to share a bed with. The novelty of her had worn off very quickly. "What do you want, Phoebe?" "You don't really have to tell me: people saw her leaving the hotel in quite a disarray. Surely you can afford her for the entire night, Fox, dearest." "Phoebe," he warned. She had to know this was dangerous ground. "I will not have you bedding that trollop with William in the next room. I will not have my son stigmatized by being seen in public with her illegitimate brat. I'm sure the judge, if we ask him, would agree. You're not the big baseball hero, anymore, dearest. You can't show up in court and dazzle them into granting you visitation, into making me move to New York. Now you're just an over-the- hill nobody trying to recapture your youth with a girl barely half your age." "I have no idea what you're talking about. Either get out or I'll call security to help you get out." Mulder was fairly certain if he laid his hands on his ex-wife at this moment, he would harm her. How dare she stand there, perfectly coifed in her Chanel suit and pumps, trying to pass for a lady, and judge Dana Scully. When she didn't move, he repeated through gritted teeth, "Get. Out." "I'm not trying to be mean, Fox. What or whom you do in private is your business, but I will not have that woman involved in William's life. If you want her for sport, I could care less, but you're parading around like you're actually going to marry her. What kind of example is that setting for William? Fox, dearest-" Phoebe stepped forward, hand raised to caress his face, and Mulder stepped back. "Fine," she said, her practiced, placid expression hardening, "If that trollop or her bastard is ever in my son's presence again, I'll go to the papers and then the court and make sure you don't see William again until he turns eighteen." She whirled to leave and he slammed his hand against the door jam in front of her so she couldn't, his face flushed. "You say one word and I'll take you apart piece by piece for all your pretty, empty-headed friends to see." He felt a wave of satisfaction as her eyes widened. "I'm 'Fox, dearest,' remember? I'm the guy who's paid for your booze and pills and shrinks and abortions for the last fifteen years. You say one word against Dana Scully and we'll go back to court. Byers will bring in your eighteen-year old boyfriends to testify to what a swell time you were and whether or not Will was there to see it. You think about that." "You won't do that to William." "You think he doesn't know, Phoebe? You think his friends don't laugh at him because of you?" Mulder's voice was still low, but his face was inches from hers. "You think you have the ultimate hold over me: you say my son's name and get whatever you want? I think I've more than done right by you. No one else is going to determine my life for me. Don't cross me on this." He dropped his arm to let her leave and turned away, disgusted. As he waited, the atmosphere in the room changed, thickened sickeningly, as Phoebe tried another tact. "I know how much you want the best for our son, Fox: the nannies, Packer Prep School, an Ivy League college, maybe a year in Europe before he marries a nice girl from a good family. I know how much you sacrificed so he could have that." She ran her fingernails lightly down his bare back and he shivered involuntarily as a memory resurfaced. "He idolizes you, Fox. You'd never endanger that by showing him it's acceptable to make the same mistakes you did. There are girls you marry and girls you don't. Do you really want him to confuse the two the same way his father does?" *~*~*~* An empty baseball stadium was not unlike an empty cathedral: one could still hear the echoes in the silence. This was the part of the American dream that didn't make the papers: the winter after the glorious season ended. Mulder could always think here: shut out the sounds falling down from the stands and focus on doing what came naturally. He tossed the ball high into the air, and then swung through, sending it sailing over the wall a few seconds later. Will's voice called to him from the dugout, "Nice. That's home run number three-hundred and sixty-two." "Three-hundred and seventy-three: you missed a few earlier. What are you doing up here, Will? Where's your mother?" "I don't know, and you didn't answer at the hotel. I wanted to talk to you. Mother made me give her my key this morning, but she hasn't been back since then. Dad, she said some awful things about Mrs. Scully." "I'm sure she did." He picked up another ball from the bucket, holding it briefly to his nose to inhale the familiar, comforting smell. Baseballs always smelled like innocence. "They aren't true, are they? Dad, she says people saw Mrs. Scully leaving your hotel room last night, but she says you're not going to marry her. I like Mrs. Scully and Emily. I'd kinda thought-" Mulder threw the ball up again, this time hitting a line drive past third base and into the outfield in perfect form. Always perfect. He'd always done everything perfectly and made it look so easy. "I'd kinda thought if you two were married I could maybe live with you instead of Mother. I guess I really don't care if it's true or not: about her not being married to Emily's father. She's a nice lady either way. Do you care, Dad?" "Do I care? How do I tell you to do one thing when I do another? How do I tell you to stay away from the wrong kind of girls, and to wait when you meet one you want to marry? Trust me, it doesn't feel like you want to wait when you're young." He swung again, so hard he almost knocked the horsehide off the old ball. "It doesn't feel like you want to wait when you're forty, either. You want to know if Scully is a nice lady? Yes, she is. What kind of example does that make me?" Will stepped over the wall of the dugout and ambled to home plate, turning up the collar of his leather jacket against the cold. "You want to know the big secret, Will? What everyone won't tell you because it's so dangerous?" Mulder lowered the bat and stared out at the empty stadium. "Love, when it's right, is everything it's supposed to be: as wonderful as hitting a homerun and as frightening as a roller coaster at the top of a hill. I think that's why people are so cynical about it. Everyone looks in the wrong places to find it, but the real thing, when it comes along: that moment is worth anything it costs you. It's just hard to wait for the real thing when there are so many quick, empty substitutes out there." "Like that cheese that comes out of a can. Mother is that stuff. Cheap and convenient and fake." "I would never say that, Will. She's your mother." "You don't have to say it; I know the difference." Still slightly taller than Will, Mulder slung one arm around his son's shoulders and carried the Louisville Slugger in the other as they walked off the field. "How'd you know where to find me? And how'd you get all the way up to the Bronx?" "You've been my father since I was born; I know you pretty well. There was only one car parked in the lot: yours, so I figured I had the right place." "But how did you afford the cab?" "I took the subway," Will replied, looking very proud as they walked through the gate and into the huge parking lot. "It's easy. You just buy the tokens and get on the right train. Mrs. Scully showed me." "When?" "Mother forgot to come get me one day after school, so I tried to find you. When I called Mrs. Scully, she came and showed me how to use the subway and the busses, just in case Mother forgot again. I guess she didn't tell you." There was an awkward silence as they stood in front of the car, not looking at each other. "Here, Will," Mulder finally said, sliding the spare key off his key ring. "This will be your key. Start the car and you can drive to the edge of the parking lot. When you turn sixteen, we'll pick out a car for you, but you can only practice with me in my car between now and then." Will's face brightened, and he almost bounded into the driver's seat. Mulder got in the passenger side, saying his prayers. He was fairly sure his son wasn't genetically destined to be a chauffeur. Christ, he had to stop listening to Frohike. This was getting ridiculous. "Give it just a little gas as you turn the key. Don't flood it. A LITTLE gas, Will!" he ordered as the Cadillac engine roared. "Now, put your foot on the brake. No, you only use one foot to drive this car, there's no clutch. Foot off the gas and on the brake and put it in gear." Mulder exhaled. "Very easily, touch the gas and the car will move. If you feel like you're going too fast, just put your foot back on the brake. Try not to forget to steer, but there's really nothing for you to hit." William, unquestionably his father's son, floored the gas, squealing the tires as though they were drag racing, then panicked, slammed on the brake, and sent Mulder face first into the dashboard. "Ah, shit, Will!" Mulder said, rubbing his forehead. "Sorry." "S'okay. Try again. Easy." After a few uneven starts, Will had the feel of things, actually making a victory lap before they reached the edge of the empty parking lot and came to a less painful stop. "Where to now, Dad?" Noticing a woman's lipstick and Mr. Potato Head's red plastic lips had rolled from underneath the passenger seat during one of Will's braking fits, Mulder replied, "Brooklyn Heights. I think I should have a nurse look at my forehead. I'll drive, though." "I can do it," Will insisted. "I'll drive. I'll drive and you can help me think up what to say to her." After walking around the car to get in on the other side, and, of course, slamming the passenger door, Will scrutinized his father's forehead as Mulder shifted the transmission into gear. "The bruise really isn't that bad." "Then we have to return her lipstick and," He picked up the red lips from the floor, "Whatever you'd call this." Will shook his head; still a bad plan. "Okay," Mulder said, pulling onto the empty street, leaving the stadium behind them. "If we get as far as the Brooklyn Bridge without figuring out something smooth to say to Scully, I'll pull over and you can hit me with the baseball bat again. That worked last time." *~*~*~* End: part I A Moment in the Sun