Begin: Paracelsus X *~*~*~* Dear Melissa, After almost fourteen years as your husband and a lifetime as your friend, I will let you in on my deepest secret – and it isn't the stack of novels hidden in my desk at work. Those are Frohike's. My secret is this: I am not all-knowing. I do not have all the answers. I stumble. I hesitate. I make mistakes. I regret. I am even afraid, which must be a shocking admission from your fearless husband. Your Fox, who can do anything, fix anything - herald of the truth, champion of the weak, and slayer of bugger-bears, kitchen mice, and Confederates - is afraid. He sits alone at his library in the middle of the night, propping his feet on the Christmas gifts hidden under his desk, and writing to a woman who cannot answer and would not understand if she could. While everyone else sleeps, he shrugs on his coat and goes outside, staring up at the immense sky as though there are answers in the stars. There are none - only strange shadows on the horizon. Sometimes I envy Moses his burning bush, Noah his white dove. I even envy Abraham the voice of God commanding him to sacrifice his only son. To have a clear-cut answer, to know what Destiny intends and to only have to act on faith… I do have faith, Melly. I make light of religion, but I have faith in God. We've had several good conversations, God and I, though there have also been times when we weren't on speaking terms. Tonight would appear to be one of those times. Yes, I am rambling. Yes, I have had a bit too much to drink. I think it shows great restraint that I have not had the whole bottle, but that is only because I spilled it and cannot find the corkscrew to open another. Is there really a single right course, Melly? I have not found it, or if I have, I am now hopelessly off-course. I wandered out of the universe where I belonged and into another universe's Hell. It is like a test where there is no right choice, where the facts and the truth are only distant relations. I am careful to whom I quote Whitman these days, so I'll rely on The Bard, on what Father would say when I'd falter: "What is your substance, whereof are you made, son?" He would say to look inside myself, to find my center and let that be my guide. I know where my center is, Melly. I know who grounds me to this world and who makes my life bearable after so much loss. I have found her. She's upstairs, asleep in our bed, with our child inside her. And that is the problem. Mulder *~*~*~* Because of her "condition," as the ladies delicately put it, rather than the weather, Dana hadn't attended the funeral, but she was waiting when he returned from the cemetery. Poppy and the rest of the staff were still at his mother's house, and Emily was asleep in the nursery, so it was just Dana in the big, empty foyer. Even Grace was nowhere to be seen. He hung his black coat on the rack, tossed his black hat on top, and ignored the water that dripped off and collected in a half-moon on the floor. He'd had an umbrella, but Sam had forgotten his, so Sam now had an umbrella. With no protection, the rain had seeped into Mulder's boots, down his collar, and under his cuffs, making him feel like a cold, damp sheep. There was nothing more miserable than a funeral in the winter rain, but at least it wasn't as perverse as a funeral on a beautiful summer afternoon with birds singing and flowers blooming. If he could bury Melly in the sunshine, he could bury his mother in a downpour. "I guess we're back to black," he commented tiredly, seeing her dull mourning dress. He tried to remember the number of times he'd seen Dana dressed up - in color and out of maternity – and realized he never had. He let his suit coat fall from his shoulders and draped it over the banister, not bothering to pick it up when it slipped off and crumpled to the floor. Dana bent to retrieve it and he told her not to, trudging past her and up the stairs. When he realized he was leaving her behind, he stopped, offering his arm to steady her as they climbed the steep staircase. "How is Samuel?" she asked, pausing for breath on the landing. "Upset. He left the service early, and he wanted to spend the night with some friend from the Smithsonian Museum instead of coming back here. He just couldn't… Mother was thirty-three when he was born; she raised him more as a son than a grandson. It's as if he's lost his mother all over again. It doesn't seem fair for one boy to lose so much. His grandparents, his mother, his sister…" "Your parents, your wife, your daughter," Dana interrupted quietly, though he'd run out of things to say. "How are you?" she asked as they reached the bedroom. It was mid-afternoon – an odd time to go to bed – but he couldn't think of anywhere else to go. "And I do not want to hear you say ‘fine.'" "I'm…" He paused, trying to put it in words. "I'm better than I should be. My father would say I'm being strong for Sam, being a man, but I just don't feel- It's like the morning after I graduated from Harvard: I got up, dressed, looked around, and realized one chapter of my life was over. It wasn't a particularly good or bad feeling so much as it was an emptiness. My mother is dead. I know I should feel more, but I just don't. If anything, I feel frightened that I don't feel more. Do you understand?" "Yes. I have been better than I should be." She helped him unbutton his shirt, stopping to examine the black armband on his sleeve. "This is pinned. Why is it pinned on instead of sewn? It will stick you." "Everyone was busy. Poppy's upset. I didn't want to bother you," he explained, unbuttoning his cuffs and collar, stripping off the damp shirt, and starting on his trousers. "Where is your undershirt? You are soaked to the skin. Why have you been standing in the rain without an undershirt?" Because he didn't have a clean one, he did not answer. Because Poppy was almost incoherent with grief and their cook and maids had been loaned to his mother's house in Georgetown to prepare for the masses who'd attended the funeral, expecting to be fed and, if they'd traveled, offered a place to stay. Because unless Dana had cooked, cleaned, sewn, or laundered anything in the last three days, it hadn't been cooked, cleaned, sewn, or laundered. "I forgot," he lied, his teeth chattering. Gooseflesh covered his chest, making the coarse hair stiffen and his nipples harden. "Now you are shivering. I want you under the covers." "I like a woman who knows what she wants," he responded, trying to muster the energy to sound sarcastic. She smiled dutifully. He told his brain to smile back, but the message didn't make it to his face. "Stay with me?" he asked wearily, feeling like he was Atlas holding the world on his shoulders. She nodded, brushing her lips over the raised scar across his chest as he sat on the edge of the bed, then laid her cheek against him. He put his arms around her, holding her close, and exhaling for the first time in days. After a few seconds, her lashes brushed his skin as she opened her eyes, but didn't pull away. He unfastened the back of her dress, then gathered it and her chemise and pulled them over her head. The stores sold maternity corsets, but she wasn't wearing one, much to her doctor's dismay. And managing her high-buttoned shoes, stockings, and garters must have been too difficult without a maid to help. She had on slippers, but she stepped out of them as he untied the waist of her petticoat and pantalets, letting them fall to the floor. She blushed and looked down, seeming awkward being undressed in front of him. The last time he'd seen her nude was the night he'd brought Samuel home, and there had been some changes, some expansions, since then. He slid under the covers, then held the blankets up as she joined him, moving slowly to accommodate her belly. Instead of rolling away so he could curl up to her back like he did as they slept, she faced him, stroking her fingertips over his cheekbones and looking at him sadly. "I wish I could make this better for you, mo rún," she said softly. "You can. You are." Silently, slowly, he moved his mouth to hers, blending their lips and then tongues. She was quicksand, pulling him farther and farther from the surface and into dangerous depths where there were no nouns: no sad eyes, polite words, and sympathetic expressions. No quiet sobs hidden behind black-bordered handkerchiefs. No formal processions, no wills, no estates, no condolences. There were only verbs: love, lick, thrust, suck. Moan, murmur, embrace, surrender. Kiss, fuck, worship, be. He kissed the bridge of her nose, the delicate velvet of her earlobes, her bottom lip, her eyelids, and the secret underside of her throat, feeling the ridges convulse as she swallowed. His kissed the white skin of her upper arm where she was ticklish, the fragile dip in her collarbone, and the textured palm of her hand. Her hand curled against his cheek, fingertips trailing down the coarse shadow of stubble. He kissed her breasts, which were swollen and sensitive, reacting to the slightest touch. There was no milk yet, so he sucked greedily, feeling her fingers run over his scalp and then grip his hair, holding him close. He kissed the arc of her belly and the backs of her knees, which were creased and lined with pale blue veins like rivers and valleys on a map. He kissed the insides of her thighs, and her toes curled in anticipation, shifting restlessly against the sheets. "I didn't know you were so beautiful," he murmured, finally feeling warm again. "How do I miss what's right under my nose?" "You are generous. I think I am more under your chin," she answered gently, teasing. "Rather have you under me," he said, then licked his lips, realizing what he'd said and what he wanted. Needed. "Dana, I shouldn't even ask…" "It is fine, I think. I am just ungainly, but I think we can." "Harvey won't mind?" "He is asleep." She rolled to her hands and knees, then arranged the pillows under her head and chest and relaxed again. "Rub my back?" she invited, shifting her legs apart. He made a low sound in the back of his throat – a blend of a growl and a sigh – which was universal to all males in any age or language. He started with her shoulders, then rolled his thumbs down each side of her spine, kneading carefully. Over her bottom and slowly down the back of her thighs, to the tips of her toes and up again. He leaned forward so he covered her, supporting his weight on his hands and knees, wanting as much of his skin against hers as possible. Quicksand, he thought, watching his body disappearing into the depths of hers. The thin veneer of ice across the surface of a bottomless lake. So deceptively calm and safe, and yet so dangerous beneath the surface. He pushed a few stray strands of hair off her neck with his nose, then whispered in her ear, "Will you fix me oatmeal? Later?" The soda crackers and strawberry jam Poppy had given him were long gone, and he hadn't thought to eat at his mother's house. He felt empty. Dana filled most of the hollowness inside him, and oatmeal would fill the rest. There was nothing more precious to a man than a woman loving him when he needed her to, the way he needed her to. "Yes, if you are hungry, I will fix you oatmeal." "Thank you," he said in advance. "With butter and brown sugar?" The way his mother had fixed it when he was small. "Yes, with butter and brown sugar." *~*~*~* Most of the wounded would have had a better chance at survival if they'd been left where they'd fallen on the battlefield. Men who lived long enough to see a doctor often died during surgery – usually the inevitable amputation - or afterward of infection, measles, mumps, or whooping cough. Even in his dream, the hospital smelled like spoiled ham and human waste, and buzzed with flies, which would have turned Mulder's stomach on a good day. As it was, eating had required sitting up and moving his arms, which had required disturbing the silk stitches holding the skin of his chest together, which hurt like hell and was too much of an effort. He and three other officers shared a room, though he hadn't seen two move in some time. The fourth had been a quiet, lanky man recovering from a head wound. He must have tried to shield his face with his hand, because he was missing several fingers in addition to an eye. He'd passed his days staring out the window, then suddenly, that morning, stood, put on his hat, and told Mulder he'd had enough – to hell with the war, he was going home. He'd given as much of his body and sanity to his country as he'd been willing to give. Mulder had just looked at him, knowing he should say something about desertion or duty, but not able to find the energy. If he could have found the energy, he probably would have gone with him. That left Mulder and two men who either were or would soon be corpses. His bed was near the door, letting him observe the mayhem of the main ward. There must have been another battle, because the litter-bearers circled, removing the dead and clearing the beds. A short Negro man made the rounds with the water-bucket and dipper, offering a drink to anyone conscious. The doctor made his way through the big room, checking wounds and bandages. About every fifth bed, he signaled the litter- bearers, and they collected another body for burial. Mulder's stayed still as the doctor checked under the cotton bandages covering his torso from just under his armpits to his navel. The bayonet had "gotten him good," as Frohike would have put it, leaving a long, bloody gash that resembled a ceremonial sash. "What about your roommates?" the doctor asked, gesturing to the other beds. "I think they're gone: those two," he pointed, trying not to move his arm. "And the one with the head wound - he went for a walk." A long walk. Home. The doctor checked, signaled the litter-bearers, then pulled the sheets over both bodies. "And you? You need anything, son?" He considered it. He'd already dictated a telegram to his father, letting him gently break the news of his injury to Melly and his mother. "Do you have a newspaper?" he asked, wondering about the world outside. "No, son, no newspaper." Mulder turned his head, looking out the dirty window at the trees. It was almost December – it might actually be December, he wasn't sure – but the hospital was in Louisville, and some of the trees still had their leaves. He had no memory of being aboard the train that had transported the wounded from the battlefield in Tennessee to the hospital in Kentucky. He only remembered the battle, looking down, seeing blood, and realizing he was badly injured, then seeing Sarah coming toward him through the tall grass. He'd closed his eyes and, when he opened them again, was in this hospital room. "Do you have an apple?" Not a baked or stewed or fried or dried or otherwise convoluted apple, but a fresh, red apple that would crunch when he bit into it and drip juice down his chin. He could put it on the table beside his bed for a while and just admire it, savor it, before he ate it. "No, no apples," the doctor answered indulgently, then moved on. Bored, restless, but unwilling to risk the pain of moving, Mulder alternated between looking out the window and staring at the ceiling, imagining he could see different things in the water stains. He turned his head when he heard silence fall over the main ward, the men settling down like lions who had spotted their prey. He looked, curious, and at first thought he was seeing Sarah again, which would mean he was dead again. His luck: twice in two weeks. He blinked and realized it was Poppy making her way through the beds, accompanied by his mother. The wounded men cleared a path as best they would, eyeing both women hungrily. Most hadn't seen a female in months, except for the nuns who volunteered in the hospital and the whores who traveled with the army under the guise of laundresses. It cost three dollars and took fifteen minutes to have laundry done, and one left dirtier than one arrived. He saw his mother pause when she spotted him, then compose herself and continue, trying to keep her skirts clear of the filth on the floor. Poppy followed, carrying a valise and trying to keep clear of the hands the more mobile soldiers. Teena seeming surprised he didn't get up to greet her. For the first time since he was five, he hadn't stood when a lady entered the room. Realizing that, Mulder gritted his teeth and swung his legs over the edge of the narrow bed. Poppy hurried to help him sit up, guiding his hand to the bedpost so he could steady himself. The room spun, his stomach pitched, and the light through the window darkened. When he could focus again, his mother was sitting in a chair beside his bed and Poppy was standing, keeping him from falling forward or back. He nodded that he was all right, and Poppy stepped away, watching him carefully. "Mother, what are you doing here?" he asked, trying not to take a deep breath. "Where's Father?" "He is in Georgetown with Samuel. He said you were wounded, but he couldn't get away," his mother answered, looking around nervously. "So I came. I was worried." Her gaze stopped on the two corpses across the room. The stretcher-bearers hadn't arrived to remove them. "I'm fine. It's barely a scratch. Mother, you can't be here." "Why can't I?" she asked, showing a defiant streak he'd never dreamed existed. Of course, he'd never dreamed she'd get on a train and travel hundreds of miles with no escort except a female servant. "I'm your mother. Why can't I be here?" "Because you can't." He took too deep a breath and winced in pain. His mother put her hand on his shoulder. He wasn't fooling her and he knew it. "There's a war on. You have to go home." "Not in Kentucky," she insisted. "Kentucky is neutral." He didn't answer that there was no such thing as neutral in this war, and that the odds were slim-to-none that his mother could find Kentucky on a map. "Fox, Melissa's downstairs. She's waiting in the lobby." He looked up, his mouth open in shock. "Melly's…" "She's scared to death. She begged to come, and I couldn't tell her ‘no.' She wanted to see you, but I didn't know it would be like this. I thought… What should I tell her? I can't bring her up here. She'll panic." He took a shallower, safer breath. "Tell her Poppy's helping me dress and I'll be right down. Just a few minutes. Go on, Mother." "All right," she agreed, standing. "Poppy has clean clothes, soap, a razor… I'll find someone to bring up hot water and towels." He nodded, wondering whom she thought she'd find to bring hot water and towels – the cockroaches, the rats, or the corpses. His mother lived in her own gilded little world, but he wouldn't have it any other way. She put her palm on his cheek, cupping his face. "Mother, I'm fine. Go wait with Melly. Keep an eye on her." "You just don't want me to see, do you?" He shook his head, and she kissed his forehead, possibly the only clean place on his body, and left. "Now how in the world you think you gonna get downstairs?" Poppy asked as soon as they were alone. "I haven't figured that out just yet," he mumbled, already exhausted. She helped him move from the bed to the chair, then unwrapped the bandages, clucking disapprovingly to herself. "This is bad, Fox." He nodded. He was aware it was bad. He was aware that by all rights he should have died on that field. Whatever plantation Voodoo medicine Poppy unleashed on him, ten minutes, some soap and water, a clean shirt, a great deal of cursing, and two morphine tablets later, he was leaning on Poppy and making his way across the lobby on opiates and willpower. Melly was standing near a window, watching the maimed soldiers around her, who were keeping an eye on her as well. She looked as out of place as a delicate rose in a cornfield, and her pretty face paled as a man missing both legs rolled past in a wheelchair. "I'm right here, honey: all in one piece," he said, and she turned, gasping in surprise. "Oh my God. Oh my God," she kept repeating, touching his face, his shoulders, his hands like she wasn't certain he was real. He'd forgotten how her touch felt: feather-light, like a butterfly's wings. "You're really all right? Really, Fox?" Poppy helped him maneuver so he could lean against the wall, propping himself up on the window ledge. "I'm just fine. It's barely a scratch." He unfastened his top two buttons, pulling his shirt collar aside to show her the very top of the scar. About two inches of it had healed cleanly and was visible above the fresh bandages; he just didn't mention that the unhealed gash continued about eighteen inches down his chest. To his surprise, Melissa kissed him on the lips, then stepped back like she might have done something wrong. "Can you come home? Do you have to stay here? This place smells bad, and you're- you're too thin. I want you to come home and get better." "I will," he promised. "Soon. Maybe in a week or two. When the doctor says it's all right. I'll be home by Christmas." Unlike Dana, Melissa didn't think deductively. If he was well enough to walk around the hospital and his only wound was the scratch he'd shown her, then he should have been well enough to get on a train and go home. He saw Poppy gesturing for him to button his uniform coat; blood was beginning to seep through the bandages and stain his shirt. He buttoned, but in his opium world, everything seemed lovely. He realized he could hear the color blue; it made a droning sound like a hummingbird's wings. And that he couldn't feel his toes, but his lips tingled pleasantly. Across the room, another officer raised his hand in recognition, but his arm seemed to continue upward for yards, stretching out like wool being spun into yarn. It seemed odd, but not noteworthy. The fairies flitting around his mother's head like little balls of dancing light whispering to her – those were odd. "I was so afraid. I was so afraid something had happened." Oh yes: his lovely, adoring wife. She was speaking, and he should probably answer. He took her hand, smiling at her. "No, nothing bad is going to happen. Please try not to worry. The war will be over soon and I'll be home for good. I promise." Melly looked at him, her trusting brown eyes seeming bottomless. They were so dark they seemed almost black, and he could see his own distorted image reflected in them. "But I'll be dead before then, Fox," she answered calmly. Mulder blinked. That wasn't the way this dream went. That wasn't the way it had happened. "You're going to make me pregnant and I'm going to kill myself and the baby," she said in the same monotone voice, like a court reporter rereading the facts. "You said you loved me. Why did you do that to me if you loved me?" "I, I-" he sputtered, trying to get his brain to function. That wasn't the way it had happened at all, but the morphine was making everything seem warped and slow and he couldn't remember the truth. He was certain the word "pregnant" would never have come out of his mouth in mixed company, let alone a lady's, so this couldn't be right. The others – Poppy, his mother, the wounded soldiers – seemed to slip into the murky background, leaving only Melissa standing in front of him, looking every bit as beautiful as she always had. "Melly, you said you wanted to. You said you wanted a baby. You said you wanted me to come to bed. I wouldn't have done it otherwise." "What else could I say? I didn't want to. Neither does Dana." "Yes, she does. How do you know about Dana?" That didn't sound like Melly at all. She was like a pie made entirely of meringue: soft and sweet and pleasing and nothing else. She would never accuse him of any wrongdoing, even in a dream. If it rained when he'd planned to go hunting, she apologized for the rain. If he was in a foul mood, she apologized for annoying him, whether she had or not. If he'd ever struck her, she probably would have apologized for being in the way of his fist. "She's smart, like Sarah. Dana knows why you married her and she's better at pretending than I am." "She loves me. She's not pretending." Melly toyed with his hand, turning it over and stroking the palm like a gypsy reading the lines. "How would you know if she was?" *~*~*~* He woke alone in the big bed, curled into a ball on the center of the mattress, arms clutching his chest. Dana was gone and the blankets had fallen to the floor, but the smell of their bodies together lingered on the rumpled sheets. That wasn't the way it had happened. Melly had asked of he could go for a walk, and his mother, thinking quickly, had said he wasn't allowed outside the hospital. After a few minutes of chitchat, they'd agreed the ladies would return to DC to get everything ready, and Poppy would stay and accompany him home as soon as the doctor said it was all right – which hadn't been for another week. And the second Melly and his mother's cab left the hospital, he'd collapsed and had to be carried back to bed. He scrambled up, pulled on the closest pair of trousers, then jogged down the steps two at a time. "Do you love me?" he demanded breathlessly, finding Dana at the kitchen stove. Emily was sitting on the floor, playing with the mixing bowls and leaning against the sleeping basset hound. "Do you?" he demanded. He ran his fingers through his wild hair. "Why did you marry me?" "What is-" "No, don't do that. Don't ask me what is wrong and don't soothe me. Do you love me?" She put a lid on the pot of oatmeal and moved it off the heat. "Of course I love you. Did you have a bad dream?" "No, don't to that either. Don't answer out of duty. Don't say you do just because you're my wife or because I love you. Do you love me?" "Yes, I love you." "Are you telling the truth? Or are you just saying that because you think it's what you're supposed to say? If you didn't love me and I'd told you that I did love you, would you answer that you did or you didn't? You'd say you did, wouldn't you?" She blinked and asked him to repeat the question. "If you didn't love me, and I wanted you to, and I loved you, and I was happy, would you tell me if you didn't love me and if you weren't happy?" Dana hesitated. "If I did not-" "I knew it. You would not tell me." She put her hands on the small of her back, massaging, and answered like he was beginning to try her patience, "If I say I love you, you say I am lying. If I would say I did not love you… I do not think there is a right answer." "Do you love me?" he demanded again. "Yes." "See – I knew you would say that. Regardless of the truth, you would say you do." She tilted her head to the side. "Then, am I supposed to say no?" His empty stomach flip-flopped nervously. "You don't love me?" "Oh, for God's sake, Mr. Mulder." "For God's sake, what?" He huffed in exasperation. "You are just being difficult. Dif-fi-cult," he repeated, enunciating each syllable. "Why did you marry me, then?" "Because you asked me?" she guessed. "Of course I asked you! I loved you! Did you expect me to just leave you in that swamp mourning that faithless son-of-a-bitch?" He closed his mouth and looked around, wondering who'd just said that. "Why did that just happen, then? Upstairs. Why did you say yes? My God, Dana, in almost a year and a half, I don't think you've ever said no. You're eight months along and you still don't say no. Is that out of some misguided sense of duty? Because you think it's part of your job as my wife? Keep my house, have my children, warm my bed? Is that all you think I want?" "I do not think you have any idea what you want." He turned and stalked off angrily, reaching the front hall before he heard her call after him, "I cannot chase you, Mulder. You will have to stop if you want me to catch up." He stopped, hands on his hips. Her skirts swished slowly against the floor as she approached, walking around him so they faced each other. "I married you because you were a good man and I wanted to go with you, wherever you were going." "Well, now that we've arrived, do you still want to be here?" "Yes. I do." He nodded thoughtfully, as though considering that on several philosophical levels. "Is there butter for the oatmeal? There's usually brown sugar, but no one's been to the market. We might not have butter." "Yes, I think there is butter." "All right then," he answered, following her back to the kitchen. *~*~*~* When he'd graduated from Harvard, his father had asked him what he wanted to do: run for office, become an ambassador… Some profession involving starched shirts, firm handshakes, and having an ancestor's signature on The Declaration of Independence. When Mulder answered, his father had chuckled, then immediately asked, "No, son, really – what do you want to do?" Over the years, he'd become a stockholder in several large newspapers and publishing houses, but The Evening Star was still the first. For the others, he traveled to New York and Boston every few months, sat in board meetings, voted occasionally, and made a nice quarterly profit, but Mulder preferred a hands-on approach to his original "ungentlemanly, unwise endeavor." It was his: earned, not inherited; built, not bought. The Washington Evening Star had grown until it was the largest building on the part of Pennsylvania Avenue known as Newspaper Row. The lobby faced the broad street, with Mulder's and the other offices off each side, and the loading docks to the rear. Frohike's typesetters and presses occupied the second floor, the reporters the third, and the Associated Press rented the fourth. Given that much square footage, he and Byers could avoid each other for days. Or, at least, until late morning, when Byers appeared in Mulder's doorway, studying his clasped hands. "We didn't expect you back so soon," he said neutrally. "I thought you'd take a few more days. It must be such a shock… Mulder, I had no idea your mother was so ill." "She wasn't. It was sudden – another stroke, the doctor thinks." Mulder straightened a stack of papers, then set them aside and folded his hands on the top his desk. Byers and Susanne had attended the funeral, so they'd already exchanged the scripted condolences yesterday. "Still, I'm sorry. I feel bad for losing my temper." Only John Byers would define showing the slightest annoyance as "losing my temper." When Mulder lost his temper, walls, crockery, and the neighbors suffered. "I feel bad for taking advantage of our friendship. I should never have asked you to read those letters. Or, at least, I should have told you what you were reading." "So we agree we feel bad," Byers responded. "She's your wife. I won't interfere again." "I wasn't aware you had interfered." Byers tilted his chin up angrily, then turned to leave. "Byers- John, I'm sorry. Close the door and sit down. Please." The door was closed, feet were shuffled, throats were cleared, and Mulder walked around his desk to sit in one of the two armchairs in front of it. "I didn't mean to accuse you of anything unseemly. That was the farthest thing from my mind." Not the farthest, really. When Dana joked about mistaking him for Frohike crawling into bed with her, he laughed because that was ridiculous. He wouldn't have laughed had she said "Mr. Byers." "I'm only trying to help by reading those letters. Dana's so… So contained. She never lets her guard down. She says she loves me, but I don't think she really trusts me. Not really. I thought-" "Why wouldn't she trust you, Mulder?" Mulder furrowed his forehead, trying to figure out if that was sarcasm, but Byers blinked innocently. "I thought she might talk to her mother," Mulder said, as though that had anything to do with reading mail he'd promised to deliver to Dana – and still hadn't delivered. "If you think I'm too friendly with your wife, it's your place to say something. Which you did," Byers responded. "As I said, I won't interfere again." There was a long, mutually disapproving silence. Dana had few friends. Even if she'd been accepted by polite society, she wasn't interested in spending her afternoons gossiping about who'd been seen with whom, and more importantly, what they'd been wearing. She liked science and literature and world events, topics seldom brought up at ladies' teas. He knew she was lonely, and Mulder told himself he tried to find time to spend with her, as though he expected to stumble over a few extra minutes at the end of the day. Time was made, not found, so somehow the minutes were never there. It probably wasn't unreasonable for her to want to talk with someone who not only shared her interests, but also spoke her language, and happened to be a happily married man. It just didn't happen to be the happily married man to whom she was married. "Am I being a jealous ass?" Mulder asked uncertainly. Byers nodded. "I was worried that might be the case." Mulder sighed, pushed a stack of ledgers aside and propped his boots up on the front of his desk. "I suppose, though, if I want anything else translated from Gaelic, I should ask someone else?" "I think that would be wise." "Why didn't you tell me I was being an ass?" Mulder asked, reaching forward to retrieve his cup of coffee. "Isn't that part of your job?" "It's like trying to tell you anything; it doesn't do any good. We have to wait until you realize it, and then we all act surprised." Mulder "uh-hummed" noncommittally in the back of his throat. "That's not really true, is it?" "Oh no, of course not," Byers answered a little too earnestly. *~*~*~* Having been mistress of a large plantation, Dana was more than competent to handle Mulder's household, but, of course, Mulder's household hadn't known that. She'd quickly had enough of "But that's not how Mrs. Mulder did it," which was code for "that's not how Poppy does it." The seventh time Dana had assigned a task and gotten that response, she'd stopped, turned, and icily informed the poor maid, "I am Mrs. Mulder." And that, except for a constant stream of complaints from Poppy for the first year, had been that. So laundry was done on Thursday instead of Wednesday, and windows were washed on Monday morning instead of Friday afternoon, since they were more likely to have guests during the week than over the weekend. Large purchases like the dressmaker or grocer were still charged to his accounts at the stores, but she instituted a ledger for household expenses. Money for the market or milkman was carefully recorded instead of Mulder just replenishing the cash box in his desk whenever it was empty. The silver chest acquired a lock and the wine cellar became off-limits to the servants. Poppy had been furious at the implication she or her staff would steal, but Mulder noticed he was spending much less on liquor, vegetables, and place settings. One of the only problematic changes was how Dana handled sewing. The majority of their clothing was ready or tailor-made, so while Dana might alter, trim, or mend a garment, she didn't spend the majority of her time sewing, like her grandmother had, nor did she quilt like Melissa had. Instead of constantly interrupting her day, Dana's method was simple: if it needed her attention, put it in her sewing basket and she would attend to it the next time she sat down. Except that was too difficult for Mulder and Sam to manage. Things in need of mending or altering were kept everywhere – in boxes and drawers, under beds, on doorknobs and hooks – except in the sewing basket. It wasn't until Dana picked up her needle and thread that they recalled where half their wardrobes were. Then they arrived with armloads of ripped pockets, loose seams, and frayed hems like pagans bringing offerings to the Textile Goddess. He and Sam made it back to the library at the same time, each vying for their turn. Dana raised an eyebrow, sighed, made herself as comfortable as possible, and asked, "Do you have the button?" as they each offered a shirt. "I lost it," Mulder responded in harmony with Sam's "It's pinned to the hem." Dana reached for Sam's shirt first, and Mulder flopped dejectedly on the sofa to wait. Emily was toddling around, reaching for things she knew she wasn't supposed to touch, then looking to Mulder so he could tell her, "No-no, Emmy." "No-no, Dahdah," Emily echoed, just checking, then moved on to the next item and continued the game. Sam busied himself behind his sketch pad, scratching away. He had an artist's knack for drawing unobtrusively, for blending into the background. It wasn't until he took the pad off the easel and moved closer that Mulder realized Dana was his son's model, and several more seconds before she did. "Oh, Samuel," she protested when she looked up. More than eight months along, in mourning, and bent over her sewing probably wasn't the way she wanted to be captured for posterity. "Please be still, just for a moment," he requested, his hand crisscrossing the paper. It looked like random scribbling, but Mulder knew it wasn't. Every detail of the portrait was already in his head, and he was just transferring it to paper. Suddenly, an image would emerge, like a sculptor discovering human form hidden inside a block of cold marble. Within a few minutes, he was finished, capturing her in a series of stark black lines and smudges. He added a few final marks, blurred an edge with his thumb, then thanked her and flipped to the next sheet and turned to Emily, who was one of his favorite subjects. She didn't hold still, but she didn't complain, either. "Do we get to look at it?" Mulder asked, curious as to how Sam saw Dana. He didn't capture a person so much as he captured the way he saw their soul. His son shook his head no, and no one pushed the issue. "All right, Samuel, your-" Dana started, then paused, putting her hand on her belly and inhaling. "Your shirt is finished. Let, let me have the other." All right?" Mulder asked, leaning toward her. She nodded, slowly blowing out a breath. He glanced at the clock, checking the time, just in case. She'd had a few pains yesterday, but they were hours apart, and she said the baby was still too high to be coming soon. Despite what she insisted, Mulder was sure the pains had something to do with them making love after the funeral last week. "Dana? Ma'am?" Sam asked, putting his sketch pad aside. "It is all right." Seeing Sam's expression, she added, "The baby kicked. It surprised me. Do you want to feel?" Sam hesitated, curious, but ill at ease. It wasn't something Melissa or even Poppy would have invited or allowed. Even working women made every effort to hide their pregnancies. While babies were celebrated, sexual intimacy bordered on sin, so being with child was evidence of a quasi- sin, however hypocritical that logic worked out to be. Upper-class children were so shielded that many reached their teens still believing storks brought babies or they were just found in the cabbage patch. Sam wasn't that naïve, but some girls were married before they saw a man shirtless, and had only a vague idea what one looked like nude. He looked to his father, who nodded, urging him to go ahead. Instead of touching her, Sam just held out his hand like he expected to have it smacked with a ruler. She took it, gently placed it on the side of her abdomen, and waited. Sam didn't move, but he looked everywhere except at Dana. "No-no, Dahdah," Emily called from underneath his desk. "No-no, Emmy," he answered without shifting his gaze from the minor miracle occurring at the other end of the sofa. "There; that is a kick," Dana told him, and Sam nodded, then pulled his hand away, embarrassed. "You're bigger. Than Mother," he said cautiously. "I'm not sure that's what Dana wants to hear right now, Sammy," Mulder interjected awkwardly. "This baby's closer to being born than… Than the other." Sam looked at Dana as if he hadn't heard that, studying her with his dark eyes. "Do you know how she died?" "Yes, your father told me." There was no response, and Mulder thought the conversation was over. Two nods, five minutes, and a dozen words: that was a conversation with Sam. "It's a sin," Sam finally added. "Poppy says she's in Hell." "You cannot know that," Dana answered calmly while Mulder was still vacillating between shock and seething. "Only God can know the depths of her soul. Suicide, freely chosen, is a mortal sin, but do you think she was able to choose? To understand what she was doing?" Mulder squirmed uncomfortably. She was breaking both his cardinal rules: don't say anything that might upset Samuel, and don't mention Melissa's illness. "No," his son answered after some consideration, then just got up and left, leaving them to stare at the back of his head. "I am going to fire her. No, kill her. I'm going to kill her," Mulder muttered under his breath. Poppy was out for the evening, but he was going to have a long, heated discussion with her as soon as she returned. "What was she thinking, telling him that? And you didn't help matters." "I answered what he asked," she responded. "I would have answered him." Although Mulder had no idea what he would have said. He was the man: lord of his domain and all. He should at least give the illusion of being in charge. "He was not asking you." That wasn't what Mulder had wanted to hear. He saw the gulf between him and his baby boy, and no amount of frantic clutching at thin air seemed to narrow it again. He saw Sam come out of his shell occasionally: becoming tearful at the funeral, putting his head on Poppy's shoulder, or talking with Dana as he had a moment ago. As the months passed, it happened more often, but it never happened with Mulder. With his father, he was polite, but as elusive as the fog. He wanted his Sammy, but he was realizing he wasn't going to get that boy back. What he'd brought home from the mines was a brilliantly talented, gentle, traumatized young man who just happened to resemble his son. Before a full-blown argument could kindle from Mulder's fear and dented pride, Sam reappeared, his sketch pad still under his arm. "What about the baby?" he asked from the doorway, looking to Dana for an answer. "Sarah?" "A child is an innocent," she responded. "Born or unborn, it is incapable of sin." There was a stilted pause, but that had been the right answer: Mulder could tell. Sam leaned against the doorframe, relaxing a little. "Thank you for fixing my shirt." "You are welcome. Did you want me to take the armband off?" Three days was the usual period of mourning for men, marked by a black armband on their sleeve. Women were expected to wear black for months before switching to grays and violets, even for a distant relative or in-law, but extended grief was unseemly for men. "No. Not now. You should rest," Sam said, never the most convincing liar. "I don't need it right now." "All right. Whenever you are ready." "Sam, I don't think-" Mulder started, but Dana shot him her scathing look: the one that reminded him of a dagger being unsheathed. "Whenever you're ready," he reiterated. *~*~*~* As always, Samuel's bedroom door was closed, and he had to unlock it before he could answer his father's soft knock. "I was just looking in on you," Mulder said uncomfortably. "I wanted to tell you goodnight." "Goodnight, sir," Sam answered politely and automatically. He was still in his shirt and trousers, but had unbuttoned his collar, rolled up his sleeves, and was holding some sheet music he must have been reading. He kept one hand on the door, waiting to close it again. "Sam, I- I've cried too." Once that unmanly admission was out of his mouth, it was easier to add, "I've had nightmares. I still have nightmares. Not just about the war, but about your mother, even about you. I've been afraid. The only man who's never afraid is a fool too blind to realize what he has to lose. And a hero is just someone with nothing left to lose." "Oh." "I'm not ashamed of you for being upset at the funeral, for crying. Or for hating the war or for not being able to come home afterward. I've never been ashamed of you. You've always felt things more deeply than other people. That's a gift, not a weakness. I'm not what my father envisioned his son would be either, but he still loved me. He was still proud of me." "I'm not what you envisioned?" "Sam, that's not what I meant. Grandfather had very high expect- He could be…" He scrambled for the right thing to say, trying to recover. "I love you, Sammy. You can't imagine how much. And I loved your mother. I still do. I hid in Dana's barn for months because I was too afraid to come home. And I hid inside myself for months, just like you are, because I was too afraid. I was afraid even to let myself be afraid. It was safer to feel nothing, but you can't go through life like that." "Oh." He was wasting his breath. Mulder could see the curtains lowering behind Sam's eyes. "Goodnight," he said again, exhaling tiredly. "Sleep well. You know where I am if you want someone to talk to." "Goodnight, sir," his son responded once again, just as politely, and closed the door. *~*~*~* He let his body fall backward onto the bed, enjoying the brief weightlessness before the heavy blankets engulfed him and he bounced to a stop. Once there, he stared at the ceiling, studying the bland white expanse. It wasn't very interesting. Stamped tin ceiling tiles were becoming popular; he should put those up – give him something to look at. "Well?" Dana asked from in front of her dressing table, brushing out her hair before bed. "Did you talk to her?" "Well, she didn't tell him Melissa was in Hell. Poppy said they were talking about my mother's funeral, about souls and spirits, and he asked if she could talk to Melissa." Dana put her hairbrush down and looked at him questioningly. "Poppy's Christian, more or less, but her mother was a quadroon Voodoo priestess: like Dori but darker skinned," he explained. "Poppy inherited all those plantation superstitions about omens and spirits and speaking with the dead. Apparently, Sam asked if she could talk with Melissa. When she said she couldn't, he assumed that meant Melly was in Hell. It was just a misunderstanding. And she said he was embarrassed about being upset at my mother's funeral, so I tried to talk to him about that. And made a mess of it." He stretched his arms above his head, letting his heels drum restlessly against the bed rail. "Poppy said he feels slighted, second best – that I pay more attention to you, Emily, and Harvey than to Samuel. That he resents it." "And you believe her?" she asked. "Why wouldn't I believe her?" "First, I know what Voodoo is and she does not need to be putting those ideas in Samuel's head. He is too vulnerable, too suggestible. And-" "She doesn't," he interrupted. "Then why did he think to ask if she could talk to the dead? He does not resent Emily. He plays with her all the time, pretending she is Melissa's daughter, I think. He seems interested in the baby, but worried, and I understand why. Aside from that, he barely seems to notice me. Or you. Or Poppy. Or anything except his music and drawing." "Why wouldn't Poppy tell me the truth?" "Because she is a liar." "Oh, be serious. Why would Poppy lie?" "That woman would say or do anything to control you. Melissa relied on her very much. You rely on her. She nursed Samuel. I think, over time, Poppy began to think of herself as the lady of your house, as your wife in everything but name. Did you know that she tells people the two of you are lovers? Or, at least, she lets them assume that you are? When you were away during the war, she took a lover who resembles you, who's even related to you. She named her daughter close to what you'd planned to name yours. You cannot see a pattern?" "I think someone's just tired and cranky," he said lightly. "Come here and I'll rub your back. Or front – whichever." He heard her lay the brush on the dressing table and footsteps as she walked to the bed. Mulder sat up, supporting his weight on his hands, and smiled at her. She didn't smile back. "Why are you treating me like I am a slow child?" "I'm sorry. I didn't mean to," he said after several tense seconds. "And please do not ignore me. If you think I am wrong, say so, but do not act as if what I say is too foolish to even acknowledge. This fascination you have with why I married you – part of the reason was because you treated me like a person instead of a possession. Now you are putting me on the shelf between your father's bust of Shakespeare and your mother's Oriental vase. I am another of your things. At least I am productive," she added, putting a hand on her swollen belly. "That must be nice." "You are not," he said slowly, leaning toward her, reaching for her hand. "Merely a possession. I never dismiss what you say. You know how much I care for you." "Yes, I do. Would you care for me on my back, on my knees, or on my hands and knees?" she answered perfunctorily, ignoring the hand he offered. There were tired purple shadows under her eyes, making them appear the final shade of blue before black, and her cheeks flushed angrily. The last six inches of her hair was still unbraided, and splayed over the front of her nightgown in thick auburn curls. She waited for his answer, and she had to wait a long time "I was just trying to think," he finally said, explaining his silence, "If anything you could have said would have hurt more." "I did not mean to hurt you. I mean, I, we-" she started, searching for words. That was one way he could tell she was upset: she lost her fluid command of English. "We cannot solve these problems in bed. If you want me, fine, but you will seduce me just to keep from talking to me. And I want to talk about this. It is important. This woman is dangerous to you and to your son. Perhaps you could depend on her once, but now her behavior is becoming more and more unpredictable - and you either cannot or refuse to see it." "What do you want me to do?" he shot back, aiming below and slightly to the left of the real problem. "Yes, I know Poppy is manipulative and dramatic, but I also know why she likes having power over men. And she doesn't have it over me. Or Sam. She'd never hurt Samuel. Yes, she uses men, but no more than they've used her over the years. Imagine what it was like for her. On Kavanaugh's plantation, there was nowhere to go, no one to help her-" "I understand more than you can imagine, but that is not the point. She did hurt Samuel. She told your fragile, fifteen-year old son that his mother and sister were burning in Hell. She upset him so much he talked to me, and he usually talks to me even less than he talks to you. And you just shrug and accept her excuse that it was all a misunderstanding? How can you do that?" "Maybe because it's the truth," he answered before he thought, then swallowed guiltily. "I was there. Melly was confused, but she understood if she cut herself, she would die, and the baby would die with her. What you told Sam: that's not the truth. Melissa knew what she was doing." "I knew it was not the truth when I said it, but Samuel needs to believe it right now. Just like you needed to believe it. How long did it take you to tell me Melissa had died, let alone how she died? Write her a few more letters, then tell me how your son should face the truth, Mr. Mulder. Samuel has already had to face enough of life's grim truths." "Yes, I am aware of that." He looked down at his feet dangling above the bedside rug. "Again, what do you want me to do? Sam loves her. He needs her. If you're confusing me with Waterston, and Poppy with Dori, you're wrong. She's my housekeeper, Melly and Sarah's half-sister, Sam's nurse, and that's all." "Poppy does not see it that way. At least, not anymore." He looked up, meeting her eyes. "Well, what if she doesn't? I love you. I loved you when I didn't have to. Even when I didn't want to." "I know. I loved you, too. Even when I do not want to. Even when I would like to shake you." "I will talk to Poppy again. I promise. Until then, would it make you feel better to shake me?" he asked. The argument seemed to be ending, but he could be wrong. He could never tell when his diversionary tactics worked with Dana and when she just tired of arguing with him and let them work. "No, unfortunately not. Can I shoot you?" "Anytime you want," he promised. "Will you lie down? Please? Sam's right: you do look so tired, Dana. You're still doing too much." "Two married people in the same bed? What will the help think?" "Hopefully, they'll be scandalized. Besides, it doesn't count if I don't undress or close my eyes," he responded, and helped her maneuver onto the bed, laying across the mattress so she faced him. "I love you," he repeated, stroking her auburn hair. "I need you to tell me the truth, and keep telling me the truth, whether it's what I want to hear or not. I need you to, because there's no one else who will. It's just us now. I have a few relatives and your mother is out there somewhere, I guess, but we're all that's…" He swallowed again, looking away. "It's going to be fine. Sam's getting better, and you're going to have this baby – hopefully in the next week - and we'll get settled in Boston, and maybe we'll get Poppy a muzzle and a nubile young love slave. I just need time, Dana. I know I keep saying that, but I need you to trust me." "I know. I do trust you. I know how hard you try. I feel foolish for getting angry when I know how bad it could be." "Will you ever tell me how bad it can be?" he asked. "Will you?" she answered. *~*~*~* As Dana slept, Mulder listened as the grandfather clock downstairs struck three o'clock, and then three-fifteen and three-thirty, slowly eating away at the remains of the night. He was too restless to sleep and too weary to get up, so he'd spent hours lurking below the surface of consciousness but just short of dreams. Though the only sound was Dana's soft breathing, the hairs on the back of his neck prickled, and Mulder opened his eyes to see his son watching them silently from the doorway. An oil lamp burned far down the hall, silhouetting Sam with an eerie yellow glow, like the eclipse of a distant son. Samuel wore loose flannel drawers, but no shirt or undershirt or socks, and his black hair fell almost to his bare shoulders. His handsome face, half-hidden in shadow, was expressionless. Mulder pushed up on his elbow, glanced back at Dana, and then at Sam. He didn't think he'd been asleep, but, once again, he hadn't heard Sam approach or the door open. "What's wrong?" he called softly, but Samuel didn't move or respond. "It's all right; we were just sleeping," he added, and then paused to rub the sand from eyes. "What is it, Sammy?" Sam continued staring at them, and, unnerved, Mulder sat up, running his hair through his hair. Dana shifted, resting her hand on the indention his body had left, but she didn't wake as he moved away. "What's wrong?" Mulder repeated as he got up, feeling like he'd been caught doing something he shouldn't. He'd dropped his trousers on the rug earlier, so he slipped them on over his drawers, then glanced around for his shirt or undershirt. "Dana was cold earlier," he lied as he dressed. "I must have fallen asleep. Did you want to talk to me?" His son still didn't seem to hear him, and continued to stand motionless in the doorway, watching the darkness like an Indian brave on guard. Sam's blank face reminded him of his mother's ghost; it was the echo of something no longer fully present. Mulder had found his undershirt, but he shivered anyway. "Sammy?" he said again, stepping closer, and then realized Sam was only sleepwalking, not lurking. He exhaled slowly. "Come on son," Mulder whispered, trying not to wake him. "Let's get you back to bed. Come on Sammy. It's all right." He put his hand gently on Sam's shoulder and turned the boy toward the hallway. Once he was pointed in the right direction, Samuel moved obediently, letting his father guide him through the dark house. Their bare feet were quiet against the cool, polished floor, and their shadows followed them on the walls, gliding after them like silent doppelgangers. When they reached the lamp halfway down the hall, though, Sam stopped, looking at the large mirror that hung above the table outside the ballroom. "Come on, Sammy," he prompted. "Back to bed. It's all right." Instead of moving, Samuel turned his head, looked at Mulder vacantly, and then back at their dim reflections in the looking glass. "We're wrong," Samuel whispered expressionlessly, like someone else was using his voice to tell a secret. "All of us." Mulder, uncertain Sam meant, nodded mutely as the hair prickled on his neck again. "We shouldn't be here," Sam said to their reflection in the same vacant voice. "We're already dead." He shivered and then swallowed dryly. "No one's dead, Sammy," he said finally. "Come on." Mulder, knowing he was too old to get spooked by dark shadows in corners, tried to guide Sam forward again, but his son didn't budge. "Not her, though," Sam added, looking back at the master bedroom where Dana slept, the tiniest bit of curiosity in his otherwise monotone voice. "Not yet." Sam looked at Mulder blankly, with a dead man's eyes, seeing something his father couldn't. Mulder's heart beat double-time inside his chest. He took a slow breath, reminding himself that Sam's eyes were open, but the boy was still sound asleep and talking the nonsense of dreams. He would not be afraid of his own son. He would not be afraid of his own son. "Back to bed, Sammy," he said, putting his hand on Sam's back and giving him a firm push. "Let's go." Sam didn't speak again as Mulder walked him back to his bedroom, then had him lay down. The boy rested his head on the down pillows, eyes still open and following Mulder as he retrieved the blankets that had fallen to the floor. "Sleep," Mulder whispered, sitting on the edge of the bed. "I'll be right here." He took another slow breath, telling himself to calm down. It was late, he was tired, and finding his son roaming the house was nothing out of the ordinary. As Mulder waited, Sam shifted, opened his eyes, and asked, "Daddy?" uncertainly as he woke, sounding a decade younger. "What's wrong?" "Nothing's wrong. You just had a bad dream." Mulder smoothed the dark hair back from Sam's forehead, his hand shaking slightly. "Go to sleep. I'll be right here. Sleep, baby boy." After a second, Sam's eyes closed trustingly and his face relaxed, looking young and peaceful. As he waited, to calm his nerves, Mulder lit the oil lamp beside Sam's bed as well, telling himself it was so his son wouldn't be frightened of the shadows. *~*~*~* Regardless of what Dana insisted, he hadn't done right by his son. All those years ago, when Bill Mulder had asked if Mulder was certain he was the father of Melissa's unborn child, he'd understood the consequences of answering affirmatively. From the moment Samuel was born, Mulder had wanted to take a broom and sweep his son's path clear. He could buy him every physical comfort and opportunity their world could provide, but it seemed he'd never been able to give Sam what the boy needed most. Melissa had spent the weeks after Sam's birth wandering around in a daze, refusing to eat or talk to anyone or leave the bedroom. She didn't want anything to do with Samuel, even when Mulder brought him to her. The doctor had explained she was young, delicate, and just had to get to know her baby. Which had seemed like an adequate explanation until his mother caught her holding the baby underwater in the washbasin. After that came a series of doctors and asylums, usually arranged by his father while Mulder was at school. By the time Samuel was four, he knew the difference between "Sad Mommy," and "Nice Mommy," and "Silly Mommy," which Mulder supposed was what one called it when Mommy painted the windows black so no one could see into their bedroom. Mulder had worried that Sam might resent Melissa, but he'd understood her far better than Mulder ever had. Sam and Melly were kindred souls, artists who found beauty in a grain of sand and passion in the contrast between middle C and F sharp. And Mulder wasn't. As much as he loved his son, he often felt as if he barely knew him. Over the years, Mulder had learned more about arias and linear perspective than he'd ever wanted to, but he was still the foreigner in his son's land, floundering and struggling to comprehend the language. Melissa had understood Sam, and, because of Mulder's impulsiveness and carelessness, Melissa was dead. He couldn't take back Christmas night he'd gone to her and she'd conceived; he couldn't take back the evening seven months later when he'd fallen asleep on the parlor sofa and she'd slit her wrists, taking Sam's unborn sister with her into death. And he couldn't take back the years he'd spent away at war or Bill or Teena Mulder's deaths. He couldn't take back the horrors Sam must have seen with General Sherman or the pain of coming home to a family and a world he was no longer a part of. Mulder could try to claw his way back to his son as much as he liked; Sam seemed to only continue drifting farther away. That afternoon, Samuel had the horse saddled and was fitting the bit into its mouth when Mulder entered the stable, still wearing his coat and hat. He slowed to a stroll as he passed the other stalls, putting his hands in his pockets and trying to look casual. "I hear you're taking a trip." Sam nodded, biting his lip in concentration as he struggled to hold back tears. Apparently, there had been some sort of unpleasant exchange between Sam and someone about fifteen minutes before he'd arrived home from work. Dana had sent Mulder hurrying to the stables to calm Sam down, but hadn't told Mulder what had upset his son in the first place. "Would you like to tell me where you're going?" "Colorado. They're mining gold there. I could mine gold." Mulder leaned against a post and crossed his arms. "Well, take your mittens. The Rocky Mountains are nippy in December. And you're a little late to be a 49er. And then there's the possibility you'll get scalped, cannibalized, buried by an avalanche, run over by a buffalo, or just starve to death." "California, then," Sam said, his voice quaking a little. "I'll go to California." "To get to California, you have to get through the Rocky Mountains. Again, there's the freeze-or-starve-to-death impasse. Why don't you have come inside and have a big, hot dinner first? Fortify yourself a little and see if you don't calm down?" His son fastened the bridle, tossed his saddlebags over the horse, and started to lead it out of the stable, refusing to meet Mulder's eyes. Dana was right; he was serious. Normally, the solution to Sam threatening to run away was to tell him that if he did, the dog would be eating his supper. He seldom made it past the end of the street, but he meant business this time. "Sammy, what happened?" Mulder asked, now without any sarcasm. "What's wrong?" "I don't belong here. I can't stay here. I'm sorry, but I can't." "What's happened, son? Dana didn't tell me." "Good," Sam answered immediately, like a skittish animal that might bolt at any minute. "Please just let me go. I want to leave. I shouldn't have ever come back." He grimaced as if struggling not to cry. "Please," he repeated earnestly. "What happened? Tell me." Sam vigorously shook his head. "Did you and Dana have a disagreement?" "Yes. I mean, no." "She's tired and she's uncomfortable right now, Sam. I'm sure she didn't mean to hurt your feelings. Let me talk to her about whatever's happened and-." Sam barked "no!" before Mulder could finish the sentence. "No, what? Sammy, you can't leave. Dana tries very, very hard to take care of you and to make you happy. She's about to have a baby; come inside and-" "I can't face her!" Sam blurted out, but then paused before he added, "She's not my mother. She shouldn't be barging around our house like she is." Mulder took a slow breath, trying to get his stomach to stop churning. "Tell me what happened." The dark head shook "no," and Sam caught his lower lip between his teeth again. "Can we- Can we go to Boston? Right now?" "Dana can't travel right now," he tried to explain. "But soon-" "No, without her. Just us. We could stay there until you divorce her." "Divorce her?" he echoed in disbelief. "You could divorce her, and we could keep Emily." "Dana's my wife just like you're my son; neither of those things is going to change. Are you serious? Divorce? Who put that idea into your head? Poppy?" Sam glanced up and asked in a voice that was suddenly frighteningly calm, "What if she dies?" "No one is going to die! Stop that! Don't even say that," he barked, and realized Sam was cowering. "God, Sammy… How can you say that?" There was no answer. Mulder exhaled slowly, trying to think of some way to pacify Sam before he disappeared into a mineshaft again. "Dana will have to stay in DC for at least a month after the baby comes. Yes, you can stay in Boston with me. Maybe you two just need a break from each other. I'm sure it is hard to see her in your mother's place, especially when she's about to have a baby. I'm sure those memories-" Instead of arguing, Sam just buttoned his coat and pulled the horse's reins to turn it toward the door. "Sam, stop. Stop and think about what you're saying. I love you, and I know you're hurting, but I love Dana too. And Emmy. And the baby. This is our family now, and it's a nice family. You're asking me to choose, and you're not even giving me a reason why you suddenly dislike Dana. You've gotten along with her for months. I know she's not your mother, but I can't bring your mother back, Sam." "I just want to leave. I don't belong here." "You do belong here. Let me talk to Dana, see-" "No," Sam said suddenly. "Please don't talk to her. Please don't. I don't want her to know." "All right," Mulder agreed. He didn't particularly want Dana to know about this discussion, either. "But I'm not letting you run off to Timbuktu." "I want to go to the London Music Conservatory. Can I go there?" "I-I can check, but I think you have to be sixteen." "Then I could go- I could go to…" Sam looked around, as if searching for a destination, then just looked lost. "I'd put you on the next train to Boston, except I'm afraid you won't make it there. I'm afraid you'd vanish again. I'm leaving on the twenty-ninth. Do you think you can make it another five days? I want to stay as long as I can, to be here when the baby comes." His son nodded, fiddling with the bridle but not really focusing on it. "It won't make a difference: whether you're here or not." Mulder felt limp, like he'd won the battle but lost the war, but looked up again. "What won't make a difference? You said something about Dana dying. Are you just upset, or has Poppy put that idea into your head too, or is it something else? Is it like knowing Grandfather was going to die? Or like when you telegraphed me about your mother?" "I don't know." "Please try, Sammy. Try hard." Sam paused, trying to concentrate. "I don't know. I can't tell. There's just so much noise here. It gets inside my head and I can't think." "All right. It's all right. You just promise me you won't go anywhere for the next five days, and then we'll go to Boston and figure things out there. And I won't mention this discussion to Dana, but I want you to be polite to her. Do we have a deal?" One last nod, and then Sam sat down heavily on a bale of hay while Mulder finished unsaddling the horse. He heard a strangled sound as he returned from the tack room, and found Sam with his face in his hands, struggling not to cry. He stood over him uncertainly, then sat with one arm, then both around his son's shoulders as he sobbed. Mulder expected Sam to jerk away and run, but he didn't, so he sat holding him, looking around the stable for some explanation as to why the sky was falling. *~*~*~* There were private academies, but it was the fashion for boys to be educated at home by tutors before attending a university. Since Mulder's father chose his tutors, his education had been heavy on military history and literature, light on art. He could quote Homer and out-maneuver Napoleon, but he didn't know Caravaggio from a crow, or Michelangelo from a magpie. It wasn't until Samuel that Mulder developed any appreciation of art besides whether he liked it or didn't like it. Sam, still missing all four of his front teeth, had taught him what a vanishing point was one afternoon in the Smithsonian Museum. Gesturing to a medieval picture of Mary and Jesus, he'd explained why it lacked the illusion of depth and looked like the figures were piled on top of each other. He'd moved on to a Renaissance painting where the figures almost leapt off the canvas, and Mulder nodded. He saw the difference and it made sense, but he'd always thought that was just the way the artists had painted them. What made a painting look real was to have everything moving toward one point and then disappearing into the distance, like water swirling down the drain. Like many things, reality was a vanishing illusion. He spun the stem of his wine glass to make a whirlpool, watching the wine slosh against the crystal sides and then accidentally over the rim and onto the letter on his desk. The ink ran purple as he tried to dry it, but he put it in the drawer anyway, knowing no one would ever read it. He heard a noise in the next room, and found Poppy in her nightgown, holding Sadie and explaining to her that Santa hadn't come yet. "Not yet," Mulder reiterated, leaning on the back of a chair in the seldom-used front parlor. The mantle was decked with holly bowers and empty stockings, and the tree glittered with silver bells and crocheted white snowflakes. "Soon. He's just down the street. You'd better hurry and go back to sleep." "She's up for good, Fox," Poppy said tiredly, then covered her mouth as she yawned. "And Sam's awake." "Is it that late already? That early?" he asked, squinting at the grandfather clock. It read four-thirty; he'd been drinking, writing, and staring at the sky all night. "I was going to light the candles on the tree, build a fire, get the p-r-e-s-e-n-t-s out…" Sober up, shave, change clothes, find some holiday cheer… When Poppy just looked at him questioningly, he mouthed, "Presents," remembering she couldn't read or write. "You watch her and I'll do it," she volunteered. At two and a half, Sadie was the only one in the house with any interest in Santa. Emily was still too little to care, and Sam had figured out the truth when he was five and the stripes had washed off his zebra. "You wanna come with me, Miss Sadie?" he asked her, taking her from Poppy and swinging her high into the air. "Help me make coffee?" Sadie was agreeable, but then Sadie was always agreeable. She said only a few words and had just started walking, but she was a pretty, happy little girl who still bore an uncanny resemblance to Samuel. By the time Mulder had a fire going in the kitchen stove and water boiling on top of it, Poppy reappeared, now in her black dress with a white kerchief and apron. He handed her the coffee beans and grinder, relinquishing his role as chef. "Make it strong," he requested, pushing his bottom lip out to amuse Sadie. She sat on the kitchen table in front of him, swinging her bare feet and watching her mother as they waited. "You need it. You sober? "I'm close," he answered. "I can see sober, but I'm not there yet. A few cups of coffee and I will be, though. I'll be okay." "You been up all night? What's wrong?" He nodded, but changed the topic. "Are you staying here for Christmas? I didn't think you were working today." "I'm not working; I'm making coffee. Besides, where would I go?" "I don't know. I thought…" He ran his fingers through his hair, trying to get it to smooth down. "Alex has his faults, but he's her father. Why don't you let him see her? Just see her. It's Christmas." A month had healed his pride and given him time to think. There were many men he respected who kept mistresses or patronized whorehouses for services that made Mulder's skin crawl. They were still doting fathers and loving husbands. He preferred his wife, but that didn't mean all men did. In fact, since marriages were usually based on convenience or monetary gain, most men didn't. He had trouble with the idea of two men together, but, rereading Whitman, had realized Alex wasn't entirely to blame for kissing him. It was possible Mulder had overreacted. He'd been known to do that once or twice in his life. "He's not her father." "He's not?" Mulder echoed, jarred back to reality. He'd only spilled the last bit of the wine. Between midnight and four, the rest had disappeared into him. "No. He thinks he is, but he's not. She's not his." "Oh," he said awkwardly. He hadn't meant to pry. "She's yours." He snorted, reaching for the cup of coffee she offered, then holding it out of Sadie's reach. "I'll take that as a complement. You wanna be my girl, Miss Sadie?" He leaned closer, putting his forehead against hers. "You're beautiful, just like my Sammy was at your age. I'll take you." "Tanta Cause," she requested, blinking endless eyelashes at him. "Tanta can't come until I have coffee. Here," he held the cup between them, "Help me blow. Blow easy, or it's going to go all over my lap." Sadie blew across the surface, managing mostly air with a little spit mixed in for flavor. When Mulder glanced at Poppy, she was still standing beside the stove, watching him. "Poppy, you can't go around saying that," he told her seriously, jumping as a Sadie blew again and a few drops of coffee hit his trouser leg. "Easy," he reminded her. "I'm not telling anyone." He sat the cup aside and turned his head to look at her. "I mean it. That's not something I want you joking about. Dana wouldn't find it funny, and neither would Sam." "I said I won't tell," she insisted. "But-" He lowered Sadie to the floor, directing her toward the dining room and hopefully out of hearing range. "But I am not her father. We-" He gestured back and forth between then. "Have never been together. I don't mind you having her here, and she's beautiful, but you will not start telling people she's my daughter." "You don't remember?" "Remembered what? I wasn't even in DC when, uh…" "No, you were in a hotel in Louisville." She was still standing beside the stove, arms folded, acting like this was a normal conversation. "With me. You remember your mother moving you from the hospital to a hotel? She and Melissa left, but I stayed with you. I took care of you." "Yes, that I remember. I also remember three dozen stitches in my chest and so much morphine I felt like I was floating." She nodded. He wet his lips and then said slowly, "Poppy, I guarantee we've never been together. I may have been drugged, but… No. Your dates don't quite match. If you're playing a joke on me… This isn't funny; this is hurtful. Do you realize how many people you could hurt?" "I won't tell anyone." He opened his mouth to protest, but she added gently, "Fox, you don't owe me anything. It happens. You didn't force me. You asked and I wanted to." He stared at her in disbelief, still a little tipsy. Jesus Christ, she seemed to believe it, and he couldn't think of any way to prove her wrong. He exhaled, hearing Dana get out of bed upstairs and Grace's claws tripping up and down the hallway between the bedrooms. Sam was up, which meant he'd gotten Emily up, which meant Dana was up before five a.m. So much for her promise to get more rest. "Did you tell Melly?" It bothered him that she hesitated, studying him and calculating her answer for half a second. If she said she had, she was not only fired, she was about to be the first woman he'd ever hit. Once again, Dana was right: she was dangerous. He was getting tired of Dana being right. "Did you tell Melly you and I were lovers? Before she died, when I was in Georgia, did you tell Melly I was the father of the baby you were having?" "No. No, course not. Fox, I'm not tryin' to cause problems. You asked who her father was. I didn't know you didn't remember; I thought you just weren't saying anything. You had Emily and Dana… She trusts you, and this would hurt her. Especially now." "Are you trying to blackmail me? Is that what this is about?" "No," she insisted innocently. "No, Fox. Never." "What have you told Sam?" he demanded, but she didn't answer. As the floorboards squeaked overhead, he considered his options, picking up his coffee again and clutching the handle angrily. "If you breathe one word – to Sam, to Dana, to anyone - I will fire you. Whether you think you're telling the truth or not, I don't care. You'll be out of a job without a reference. No nice family will hire you and you know where you'll end up. Am I making myself clear?" "I won't tell anyone," she repeated, backing away, shivering even though the kitchen was warm. "I want you out of my house. You're not staying here at night and the only reason you still have a job at all is because Sam loves you. Find a flat and I'll pay the rent, but I want you out. Today. This morning." He set his cup down hard, spilling it, and without looking back, went to help Dana down the stairs. To his surprise, Sam was carrying Emily on his hip and walking slowly with Dana, offering his arm in case she lost her balance. For a boy who'd been discussing her death twelve hours earlier, Sam was being a perfectly solicitous escort. There was a procession: Grace would waddle a few steps below them, then wait, watch, and wag until she caught up. "Good morning. Merry Christmas," he greeted them, forcing a smile and taking Emily from Sam. "Merry Christmas," Sam answered while Dana caught her breath. The doctor kept coming by to check on her and promising it would be "any day now, Mrs. Mulder." From the look of her, any minute was more like it. "Cwith-mas," Emily added, giving his scruffy cheek a wet kiss. *~*~*~* End: Paracelsus X