HRC DECLARES: 'JUSTICE WAS SERVED'
Matthew Shepard Murder Suspect Pleads Guilty To Felony Murder
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
April 5, 1999
WASHINGTON - The Human Rights Campaign expressed satisfaction today as
the first of two men charged with murdering Matthew Shepard pleaded guilty in a Laramie,
Wyo., court.
"Justice was served, and we applaud the authorities in Wyoming for
bringing closure to this phase of the murder trials, " said HRC Political Director
Winnie Stachelberg. "However, this brutal murder underscores the dire need to send a
strong message that these hateful acts are not tolerated anywhere in America by passing
strong state and national hate crimes laws. Until this happens, justice will remain
inconsistent and elusive for many hate crimes victims."
Russell A. Henderson pleaded guilty today to the felony murder, robbery
and kidnaping of Shepard, a University of Wyoming student. Henderson was sentenced to two
consecutive life terms.
According an Associated Press report, defense attorney Wyatt Skaggs
said that Henderson simply watched while co-defendant Aaron J. McKinney beat Shepard with
the butt of a gun last October. Shepard died in Fort Collins, Colo., five days after his
body was found lashed to a buck fence in Wyoming. Skaggs also claimed that the fatal
beating was not premeditated.
McKinney is slated to stand trial in August on charges of first-degree
murder, aggravated robbery and kidnaping. If convicted, he could receive the death
penalty.
Henderson's girlfriend pleaded guilty Dec. 23 to being an accessory
after the fact and is awaiting sentencing. McKinney's girlfriend is scheduled to go on
trial in May on an accessory charge.
At a press conference in Washington on March 23, Shepard's mother, Judy
Shepard, spoke of the need to pass stronger hate crimes laws, including the Hate Crimes
Prevention Act. The bill, introduced in early March, would extend current federal hate
crimes protection to cover gender, sexual orientation and disability.
"There is no guarantee that these laws will stop hate crimes from
happening. But they can reduce them," Mrs. Shepard said at the news conference.
"They can help change the climate in this country, where some people feel it is OK to
target specific groups of people and get away with it. If just one potential perpetrator
gets the message of this legislation and there is one less victim, then it will be
worthwhile."
Hate crimes based on sexual orientation were up 8 percent in 1997,
according to the latest FBI statistics. Sexual orientation was the third-highest category
of hate crimes behind race and religion and represented 14 percent of all hate crimes
reported.
Calls for passage of the Hate Crimes Prevention Act accelerated in the
aftermath of three brutal murders that shocked Americans. Last year, white supremacists
dragged James Byrd, a black man, to his death behind a pick-up truck in Jasper, Texas.
Shepard was targeted because he was gay. And on Feb. 19, Billy Jack Gaither was beaten to
death and burned on a pile of tires in Sylacauga, Ala. Two men, Charles Monroe Butler, 21,
and Steven Eric Mullins, 25, confessed to killing Gaither because he was gay, Coosa County
Sheriff's Deputy Al Bradley told The Associated Press.
Currently, hate crimes monitoring and enforcement consist of a
patchwork of laws that offer citizens varying levels of legal protection depending on
where they live. Twenty-one states and the District of Columbia have hate crimes laws that
include sexual orientation. Twenty-one states have laws that do not include sexual
orientation. Eight states have no hate crimes laws at all.
The Hate Crimes Prevention Act would allow local law enforcement
authorities to use federal assistance in the investigation and prosecution of hate crimes.
This key aspect of HCPA is why it has broad support from notable law enforcement agencies
and state and local leaders, including 22 state attorneys general, the National Sheriffs
Association, the Police Foundation, former Attorney General Dick Thornburgh and the U.S.
Conference of Mayors.
Two federal hate crimes laws include sexual orientation as a protected
group. The Hate Crimes Statistics Act of 1990 requires the FBI to collect statistics on
bias-motivated crimes. The Hate Crimes Sentencing Enhancement Act of 1995 provides for
tougher sentencing when it is proven that the crime committed was motivated by bias.